Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!

The NHL Playoffs - Leave 'em alone!

August 7, 2018, 11:40 AM ET [5 Comments]
Paul McCann
Nashville Predators Blogger •Predators Radio Network • RSSArchiveCONTACT
Y’know… reading Ottawa blogger Trevor Shackles’ well written piece on fixing the NHL playoff structure got me to thinking. Does the NHL playoffs need “fixing?” I say no… I mean all the complaining about the NHL playoff system is kinda interesting but I think it is just fine the way it is. But to see all the complaining, I can only assume that someone, somewhere, wrote on a couple of stone tablets that the best team must always make the conference final… forever and ever Amen.

What a steaming pile of crap.

The rivalries that are being built out of this format are worth it. Before this season, I really didn’t give a hoot when the Preds played Winnipeg… after last season’s epic playoff showdown, I have October 11, January 17, March 1 and March 23rd circled in gold on my calendar. The Avalanche have been a “meh” game for years, now… after a great first round series… I can’t wait for them to hit town on November 27th. The seeds of rivalries were sown last playoff season and the potential to grow them is very real.

The current playoff system rewards you for winning a division, rewards stronger divisions by an opportunity to get more playoff slots in the division and frankly, has really helped build some regional rivalries, not only in the playoffs, but the regular season as well. Is the current system perfect? No. I don’t think that a division winner should have to travel across two time zones to play a West Coast wild card team, but that is a small quibble that has more to do with geography than the design of the playoffs. In this observer’s opinion… the benefits far outweigh the detriments.

In playoff years since the system has been in place we have seen California teams play each other multiple times, two freeway series in the first year as LA took on both Anaheim and San Jose on their way to the Cup… under the old system that just didn’t happen very much, if at all. Since the new system the California teams have played each other in five different series. The Pacific Division battles have been epic.

While Pittsburgh and Washington have never really liked each other… it was the divisional play, both regular season and consistent playoff meetings that has turned that rivalry into a blood feud. The Metro has helped Columbus build some bad blood between their divisional opponents. This system has been good for rivalry building.

The big issue in this seems to be that some pundits don’t like seeing great matchups early in the playoffs. It almost like a rule needs to set that Washington and Pittsburgh should only meet in the conference final. Would the Caps/Pens series or the Preds/Jets series be better if they were in the conference final? Nah…

These folks kvetch about President’s Trophy winners not having an easy path to the conference final, but first round upsets are a hallmark of the playoffs in almost every sport.

Wait… what? Hold on a minute… should there be an “easier” path to the conference final?

Where is it written that a benefit of being the best regular season team should be a red carpet directly to the final? That concept is simply ludicrous! The benefit of winning the President’s Trophy is home ice throughout the playoffs… period. The fact that the President’s Trophy winner has the best chance to win the Cup out of any seeded position is proof, proof that the benefit earned in the regular season give a significant advantage… there is no need for more.

Playoff matchups make rivals. Nashville’s rivalry with Chicago didn’t really ripen until the sweep of 2017. Since the Predators and Red Wings were separated into different conferences, the passion of the Detroit / Nashville rivalry has faded.

Once Seattle is officially added and the league is at 32 teams, there may be another realignment of divisions and playoffs. I hope not… because two divisions of eight teams in each conference makes the perfect divisional play down… top 4 in each division fight it out. Division winners meet in the conference final. Simple, clean and will drive these budding rivalries to even more intensity.

The current system is working… the ratings show it, the matchups continue to be compelling… just leave it alone.



Random Notes

- Really funny Twitter exchange as the Ryan Johansen / Ryan Kesler feud heated up again on Sunday. Just proving that Johansen has his feet propped up on Kelser’s kitchen table, enjoying a cup of coffee and a donut as his residency inside Kelser’s head continues.

- Interesting column from Greg Wysynski on ESPN.com asking what teams will crack 100 points next season. He does call Nashville as one of them.

- Speaking of columns… really good column from Jeremy K. Gover on 102.5 the Game’s website on bringing back neutral site games.

- The NHL is charging to watch practice during the Global Series in Finland this year… wow…

- A one year deal for William Karlsson for 5.25 million. A risky move for Vegas. Sure, that’s a bargain for a 40+ goal scorer, but if he does it again this season, his demands will rightfully double. Bears watching.

- The Jeff Skinner trade to Buffalo is one of those that will be pointed to when the Sabres make the playoffs next April.



SlapShot Radio’s is now prepping for it’s 11th season. As the longest running hockey show in the region, SSR feeds hockey fans what they crave… intelligent, fun, entertaining talk about their favorite sport and we do it from the opening of training camp all the way through UFA day. We are on every Wednesday night on the Predators flagship station, 102.5 the Game.

We have been delivering great hockey talk to the most energetic and engaged fans in radio and advertising with us drives results at a reasonable price. Just ask our sponsors… including day one sponsor Dr. Jane Bacon at Hermitage Family and Cosmetic Dentistry … make your appointment at (615) 872-7762 and Patrick J. Brown’s Farmer Insurance Agency in Mt. Juliet… I switched to them a few years back and their service has been incredible! Give Pat and his team a call at 615-288-2086.

Advertisers… reach out to me in order to access our activated listener base though great preseason advertising deals available for our eleventh season. You can send me a message on the SlapShot Radio Facebook page or by messaging me right here on HockeyBuzz.

You can also keep up with all the goings on with SlapShot Radio by following the show on Twitter @SlapShotRadio1 … Also... make sure to "like" SlapShot Radio on Facebook... here's the link.

If you are outside of the listening area, listen live online at The Game website or check out the podcast about two hours after the show at on SoundCloud.


KINDLE USERS: Please subscribe to Predators Buzz, a one-stop feed for all things Predators-related on HockeyBuzz. Your subscription includes a free 14-day trial and is just 99 cents per month thereafter. For more information, click here.
Join the Discussion: » 5 Comments » Post New Comment
More from Paul McCann
» Ramping it up
» Coming home with 4 of 6
» Desperate... and getting serious
» Game Night - "Desperation" Time?
» Hitting the Road