Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Blog World :: Bill Meltzer: Meltzer's Musings: Rout on the Island, O'Reilly Rumor
Author Message
isaiah520
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: "All train compartments smell vaguely of sh*t. It gets so you don't mind it"
Joined: 12.26.2006

Feb 19 @ 9:07 PM ET
His team is loaded but the scandal they under went this year will cripple them for the future

http://unitedstatesofhock...wks-with-heavy-sanctions/

- ob18

should prepare him for homer's cap adventures...
moylander
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Chicago, IL
Joined: 06.14.2011

Feb 19 @ 9:08 PM ET
reason 2 and 1 to fire Paul Holmgren
- watsonnostaw



Call me crazy but I still think the flyers will eke into the playoffs this year.
SuperSchennBros
Location: Not protected by the Mods...I mean Mob. Take your best shot!
Joined: 09.01.2012

Feb 19 @ 9:11 PM ET
Call me crazy but I still think the flyers will eke into the playoffs this year.
- moylander

Crazy!
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:13 PM ET
I favor Schenn more as well. I like his speed, physicality, and offensive upside a lot. I'm glad he is finally starting to show some consistency in his game. Coots has a great all around game and some hockey smarts to boot. At 6'3"-6'4" he could be a beast when he adds some muscle.

Both he and Coots need to win more faceoffs - neither has done well there.

- moylander


I like both players a lot. And I think that both are going to be very good players. But if both players reach their potential. Couturier will be a much better player then Brayden Schenn in my opinion.
FlyerMike18
Philadelphia Flyers
Joined: 03.07.2009

Feb 19 @ 9:16 PM ET
Identify the following two players:

Player A GP 12 5 points +1
Player B GP 16 5 points E

- PLindbergh31



i'm guessing player A is shea weber?

B... luke? coburn?

EDIT: i cheated

i know the big guy is having a rough start, but that's exhibit A for: "normal stats don't always tell the whole story"
moylander
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Chicago, IL
Joined: 06.14.2011

Feb 19 @ 9:19 PM ET
Crazy!
- SuperSchennBros



CRAZY!?!?! I was crazy once....
stveshdy
Philadelphia Flyers
Joined: 06.28.2010

Feb 19 @ 9:23 PM ET
I like both players a lot. And I think that both are going to be very good players. But if both players reach their potential. Couturier will be a much better player then Brayden Schenn in my opinion.
- MJL


What Flyers defenseman has the best potential?
watsonnostaw
Atlanta Thrashers
Location: Dude has all the personality of a lump of concrete. Just a complete lizard.
Joined: 06.26.2006

Feb 19 @ 9:25 PM ET
What Flyers defenseman has the best potential?
- stveshdy

Sbisa
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:25 PM ET
What Flyers defenseman has the best potential?
- stveshdy


There isn't a big pool to choose from. Timonen is 38. Grossmann and Coburn are what they are. Meszaros has some room to grow. But clearly in terms of future potential. Hands down Luke Schenn.
SuperSchennBros
Location: Not protected by the Mods...I mean Mob. Take your best shot!
Joined: 09.01.2012

Feb 19 @ 9:27 PM ET
I like both players a lot. And I think that both are going to be very good players. But if both players reach their potential. Couturier will be a much better player then Brayden Schenn in my opinion.
- MJL

I wish I could agree. After watching Schenn in the 2010/2011 World Juniors, I truly believe this kid is something special. He carried that team on his back. A team Sean Couturier was apart of. Normally in those tournaments the teams are stacted and the Canadian teams win by committee but Brayden was a clear standout that could translate to the NHL and hopefully someday compliment giroux in important situations. Game on his stick, we pulled our goaltender and we need a goal to force Over Time. This is the player I expect Brayden Schenn to be. A big stage player.

I also feel Brayden Schenn was an important player in the playoffs last season against the Penguins.
stveshdy
Philadelphia Flyers
Joined: 06.28.2010

Feb 19 @ 9:31 PM ET
There isn't a big pool to choose from. Timonen is 38. Grossmann and Coburn are what they are. Meszaros has some room to grow. But clearly in terms of future potential. Hands down Luke Schenn.
- MJL


Are you sure about that?
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:39 PM ET
I wish I could agree. After watching Schenn in the 2010/2011 World Juniors, I truly believe this kid is something special. He carried that team on his back. A team Sean Couturier was apart of. Normally in those tournaments the teams are stacted and the Canadian teams win by committee but Brayden was a clear standout that could translate to the NHL and hopefully someday compliment giroux in important situations. Game on his stick, we pulled our goaltender and we need a goal to force Over Time. This is the player I expect Brayden Schenn to be. A big stage player.
- SuperSchennBros


This plays right into why I think that if both players meet their potential, Couturier will be the better player. You mention important situations. Is needing a goal late in the game the only important situation in a game? Later in his development, needing a goal, Couturier, same as Schenn, is likely going to see icetime in that situation. Both will and already do play the PP. How about when the team is up a goal late in a big game? Couturier is likely to be double shifted, while Schenn sees his icetime reduced. How about on a key penalty kill? Who is going to be out there? Or how about while also providing offense, who is going to be matched up against other teams top lines? Now don't get me wrong, offensive players like Schenn that can score and are good on the forecheck are important to a team. But unless Schenn drastically improves his all around game. Especially his play in his own end. Which right now is not very good. He's not going to be an all situations player. While Couturier is. That is why again, if both players reach their potential, Couturier will be the better player.
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:39 PM ET
Are you sure about that?
- stveshdy


Absolutely, there is no question about it.
SuperSchennBros
Location: Not protected by the Mods...I mean Mob. Take your best shot!
Joined: 09.01.2012

Feb 19 @ 9:47 PM ET
This plays right into why I think that if both players meet their potential, Couturier will be the better player. You mention important situations. Is needing a goal late in the game the only important situation in a game? Later in his development, needing a goal, Couturier, same as Schenn, is likely going to see icetime in that situation. Both will and already do play the PP. How about when the team is up a goal late in a big game? Couturier is likely to be double shifted, while Schenn sees his icetime reduced. How about on a key penalty kill? Who is going to be out there? Or how about while also providing offense, who is going to be matched up against other teams top lines? Now don't get me wrong, offensive players like Schenn that can score and are good on the forecheck are important to a team. But unless Schenn drastically improves his all around game. Especially his play in his own end. Which right now is not very good. He's not going to be an all situations player. While Couturier is. That is why again, if both players reach their potential, Couturier will be the better player.
- MJL


How reduced were Crosby and Malkins roles in favor of Jordan Staal on key situations? Will Schenn and Giroux ever become Malkin and Crosby? Probably not but you can compare the roles and how important we will need Schenn and Giroux to be. Schenn and Giroux will likely to see time together. While Couturier needs time to grow his offensive game, Schenn has time to improve his defensive game. At lower stages of Brayden Schenns career, he was known as a two way player, which is why he was somewhat compared to Mike Richards.
moylander
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Chicago, IL
Joined: 06.14.2011

Feb 19 @ 9:49 PM ET
This plays right into why I think that if both players meet their potential, Couturier will be the better player. You mention important situations. Is needing a goal late in the game the only important situation in a game? Later in his development, needing a goal, Couturier, same as Schenn, is likely going to see icetime in that situation. Both will and already do play the PP. How about when the team is up a goal late in a big game? Couturier is likely to be double shifted, while Schenn sees his icetime reduced. How about on a key penalty kill? Who is going to be out there? Or how about while also providing offense, who is going to be matched up against other teams top lines? Now don't get me wrong, offensive players like Schenn that can score and are good on the forecheck are important to a team. But unless Schenn drastically improves his all around game. Especially his play in his own end. Which right now is not very good. He's not going to be an all situations player. While Couturier is. That is why again, if both players reach their potential, Couturier will be the better player.
- MJL



to me it's like choosing between mike richards and jordan staal.
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:51 PM ET
How reduced were Crosby and Malkins roles in favor of Jordan Staal on key situations? Will Schenn and Giroux ever become Malkin and Crosby? Probably not but you can compare the roles and how important we will need Schenn and Giroux to be. Schenn and Giroux will likely to see time together. While Couturier needs time to grow his offensive game, Schenn has time to improve his defensive game. At lower stages of Brayden Schenns career, he was known as a two way player, which is why he was somewhat compared to Mike Richards.
- SuperSchennBros


We'll see if Brayden Schenn can develop his two way game. But he has a long way to go. I assure in key defensive situations and key penalty kills, J Staal was on the ice ahead of either Malkin and Crosby.
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:54 PM ET
to me it's like choosing between mike richards and jordan staal.
- moylander


Not really. Both Mike Richards and Jordan Staal are all situation players. And known for their defensive work. Right now, B Schenn isn't showing a lot of promise on the defensive end. Surely at his age and experience he can improve in that area. But I don't see him having the all around game that Couturier will have.
SuperSchennBros
Location: Not protected by the Mods...I mean Mob. Take your best shot!
Joined: 09.01.2012

Feb 19 @ 9:57 PM ET
to me it's like choosing between mike richards and jordan staal.
- moylander

Forsberg and Sakic. Zetterberg and Datsyuk. Crosby and Malkin. These are a handful of skilled players who have learned how to play together and part. Both have proven to be dynamic on the big stage. I pray for the same type of career for Giroux and Schenn together. Maybe Couturier can become equally as awesome but we'll see.
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 9:59 PM ET
Forsberg and Sakic. Zetterberg and Datsyuk. Crosby and Malkin. These are a handful of skilled players who have learned how to play together and part. Both have proven to be dynamic on the big stage. I pray for the same type of career for Giroux and Schenn together. Maybe Couturier can become equally as awesome but we'll see.
- SuperSchennBros


I really hope you're right that Brayden Schenn will reach the level of those players that you mention here. But that is aiming very high. All Hall of Fame level players. Maybe not Zetterberg, but the rest for sure.
SuperSchennBros
Location: Not protected by the Mods...I mean Mob. Take your best shot!
Joined: 09.01.2012

Feb 19 @ 10:11 PM ET
I really hope you're right that Brayden Schenn will reach the level of those players that you mention here. But that is aiming very high. All Hall of Fame level players. Maybe not Zetterberg, but the rest for sure.
- MJL

Schenn is in his second season. The first he spent the first half hurt. The second saw the entire NHL locked out. Many possible hall of fame players had slow starts to their careers. Joe Thornton comes to mind. Even if Giroux and Schenn become a marginal hall of fame duo like Thornton and Marleau, same rules apply.
Jsaquella
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Bringing Hexy Back
Joined: 06.16.2006

Feb 19 @ 10:12 PM ET
Call me crazy but I still think the flyers will eke into the playoffs this year.
- moylander


I'd call you crazy, but I agree with you.
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 10:15 PM ET
Schenn is in his second season. The first he spent the first half hurt. The second saw the entire NHL locked out. Many possible hall of fame players had slow starts to their careers. Joe Thornton comes to mind. Even if Giroux and Schenn become a marginal hall of fame duo like Thornton and Marleau, same rules apply.
- SuperSchennBros


Anything is possible. But I would not label B Schenn as having the potential for a Hall of Fame career. But player evaluations aren't an exact science. And you never know. Let's hope you're right.
Jsaquella
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Bringing Hexy Back
Joined: 06.16.2006

Feb 19 @ 10:22 PM ET
Forsberg and Sakic. Zetterberg and Datsyuk. Crosby and Malkin. These are a handful of skilled players who have learned how to play together and part. Both have proven to be dynamic on the big stage. I pray for the same type of career for Giroux and Schenn together. Maybe Couturier can become equally as awesome but we'll see.
- SuperSchennBros


The difference, thus far, in their NHL careers has been in display of hockey sense as a defensive player.

Couturier has shown a lot in that regard, being in the right position and making smart plays in his own end. His work against Malkin in the playoffs was stunning given his age and what was asked of him.

Schenn, meanwhile, has not shown the same solid two way play he did as a junior. He's shown the offensive ability, and definitely the physical side of things, but the defensive side has been lacking at times.

Schenn has shown more of the offensive side, especially this season, but he's also been given much more of a chance to display his offensive ability. Spent a lot of time last year playing with Briere & Simmonds and saw more than a minute per game more on the PP last year.

Couturier's defensive abilities saw him get more PK time and lesser linemates, even this year.

Both have show they are special players and have tons of potential. I lean towards rating Couturier a bit higher because he's shown how good he can be as a defensive player at the NHL level. Schenn has to show more hockey sense in that regard, and hockey sense isn't teachable
MJL
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Candyland, PA
Joined: 09.20.2007

Feb 19 @ 10:28 PM ET
The difference, thus far, in their NHL careers has been in display of hockey sense as a defensive player.

Couturier has shown a lot in that regard, being in the right position and making smart plays in his own end. His work against Malkin in the playoffs was stunning given his age and what was asked of him.

Schenn, meanwhile, has not shown the same solid two way play he did as a junior. He's shown the offensive ability, and definitely the physical side of things, but the defensive side has been lacking at times.

Schenn has shown more of the offensive side, especially this season, but he's also been given much more of a chance to display his offensive ability. Spent a lot of time last year playing with Briere & Simmonds and saw more than a minute per game more on the PP last year.

Couturier's defensive abilities saw him get more PK time and lesser linemates, even this year.

Both have show they are special players and have tons of potential. I lean towards rating Couturier a bit higher because he's shown how good he can be as a defensive player at the NHL level. Schenn has to show more hockey sense in that regard, and hockey sense isn't teachable

- Jsaquella


Well said. A lot of fans when looking at forwards, only think abut the offensive side of the puck. And how many goals and assists the player will rack up. Instead of the all around game and the other areas of play that are so important to winning. A player that can put up points, while also being able to check any teams top line or top player, and play in any situation. Is an incredibly valuable player in this League. Much more valuable then a strictly offensive player. Unless that player is an offensive superstar such as a Malkin or Stamkos.
Flyskippy
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Ignoreland, GA
Joined: 11.04.2005

Feb 19 @ 10:30 PM ET
Are you sure about that?
- stveshdy

Yes, his hands are down. On his keyboard.
Page: Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30  Next