if we believe that couts will exceed schenn as a better overall player, then schenn is the guy who is a better match as a pmt for shattenkirk. schenn has more polish right now in some areas, but he's more physically mature.
i think the growth we expect from schenn in his overall game seems to be somewhat underrated, but i do think that couts will be the better player in 2-3 yrs. couts needs to work on his skating, particularly his 1st couple of strides and his balance, along w/ some overall strength training. more than anything though, he just has to grow into his body and we can only push that so much.
- isaiah520
I wouldn't trade either for Shattenkirk. He's a good defenseman, but he's not a true number one.