Not really because they wouldn't score 30 outside of PA. Neither of them or on Cally's or Nash's level
- sbroads24

They don't need to be...what they bring is perfect for this team....compliments to the superstars. Either of those guys would be welcome on every other team in a heartbeat

UFA?
- mighty13duck

He will be resigning in Pittsburgh

He will be resigning in Pittsburgh
- Oneonta Penguin

Take NAbby to backup MAF next year. Hes great in the playoffs

How is he better? He plays 2nd line minutes against lesser competition and scores less? Both play D and kill penalties.
- sbroads24

You are fighting a losing battle on this board relative to this.

UFA?
- mighty13duck

He is. But he is very established here with his family, kids and schools. He's already turned down more money to leave. I think the Pens give him a nice raise and he stays.

Actually, they are on Cally's level, because he has never scored 30 either.


You seem so hellbent saying that Nash is this monster. You are on the wrong board trying to see him over Callahan. We know who is better.
- Oneonta Penguin

Please don't try to compare Kunitz or Dupuis to Nash. I said Callahan and Nash are better than both of them. Show me the great seasons Kunitz and Dupuis had outside of Pitt, and I'll show you Nash's numbers in Columbus

Take NAbby to backup MAF next year. Hes great in the playoffs
- mighty13duck

We have Vokoun for another year. No thanks on Nabby

He is. But he is very established here with his family, kids and schools. He's already turned down more money to leave. I think the Pens give him a nice raise and he stays.
- madmike71

Oh didn't know that.

How is he better? He plays 2nd line minutes against lesser competition and scores less? Both play D and kill penalties.
- sbroads24

Stats are great, we all use them, but I'll trust my eyes first and more times than not I believe I am accurate with player assessments.

Please don't try to compare Kunitz or Dupuis to Nash. I said Callahan and Nash are better than both of them. Show me the great seasons Kunitz and Dupuis had outside of Pitt, and I'll show you Nash's numbers in Columbus
- sbroads24

Who is comparing Kunitz or Dupuis to Nash? You made a retarded comment as to why we would take Callahan over Nash because he hasn't scored 30 either. Dupes and Kunitz are perfect fits for Pittsburgh. Hell, they would be your second and third best players behind Vanek. Then again, we know Vanek has no consistency at all and both Dupes and Kunitz have better consistency.

Please don't try to compare Kunitz or Dupuis to Nash. I said Callahan and Nash are better than both of them. Show me the great seasons Kunitz and Dupuis had outside of Pitt, and I'll show you Nash's numbers in Columbus
- sbroads24

Kunitz is a Cup champion with Anaheim while playing in a top 6 role.

That sounds incredible! My two favorite types of beers are porters/stouts and IPAs! I'll have to grab some the next time I'm in Pennsylvania for a Pens game.
- kill.monsters

I would obviously recommend it. Not sure how readily available it is in western PA though.

WTF is up with 2 off nights between home games than only 1 off day when travel is needed? Well done NHL, well done. .

Kunitz is a Cup champion with Anaheim while playing in a top 6 role.
- Gunner Staal

I was just about to say that. Kunitz was great in that series. Fun time to be a ducks fan back then

Stats are great, we all use them, but I'll trust my eyes first and more times than not I believe I am accurate with player assessments.
- Gunner Staal

Which is why you feel the need to drop by the Sabres blog and drop Corsi stats in the middle of discussions right? Callahan faces 2nd pairing defensemen, scores less than Nash his entire career, has played on a better team his entire career, both have been team captains, one was on the first line for team Canada I might add. I don't see how Callahan is better.

Stats are great, we all use them, but I'll trust my eyes first and more times than not I believe I am accurate with player assessments.
- Gunner Staal

That's the thing... 30 seconds left in the game and you have a choice of puttying Cally or Nash on the ice.... who are you going to choose? I don't trust Nash to win a puck battle at all.

Kunitz is a Cup champion with Anaheim while playing in a top 6 role.
- Gunner Staal

And? Would Nash have not been on ANA top 6 or something?

Which is why you feel the need to drop by the Sabres blog and drop Corsi stats in the middle of discussions right? Callahan faces 2nd pairing defensemen, scores less than Nash his entire career, has played on a better team his entire career, both have been team captains, one was on the first line for team Canada I might add. I don't see how Callahan is better.
- sbroads24

You also think Tyler Myers and Derek Roy are good. We don't watch the same games

Who is comparing Kunitz or Dupuis to Nash? You made a retarded comment as to why we would take Callahan over Nash because he hasn't scored 30 either. Dupes and Kunitz are perfect fits for Pittsburgh. Hell, they would be your second and third best players behind Vanek. Then again, we know Vanek has no consistency at all and both Dupes and Kunitz have better consistency.
- Oneonta Penguin

Oh my lord

You also think Tyler Myers and Derek Roy are good. We don't watch the same games
- Gunner Staal

You also thought Jordan Staal was great and would never be traded? Remember?

You also thought Jordan Staal was great and would never be traded? Remember?
- sbroads24

He is very good.

Just an FYI for others, he thinks a Derek Roy is way better than Jordan Staal.

Next ill be told how good Ennis and Hodgson are.

Kunitz is a Cup champion with Anaheim AND PITTSBURGH while playing in a top 6 role.
- Gunner Staal

I made a slight correction for you.

Oh my lord
- sbroads24

Give me names if you disagree. What slop are you going to put down? Jason Pominville doesn't play for Buffalo anymore.

He is very good
- Gunner Staal

And Myers will be too. They both has awful seasons. Derek Roy also has a very good career to look at as well. And I hate Derek Roy

Give me names if you disagree. What slop are you going to put down? Jason Pominville doesn't play for Buffalo anymore.
- Oneonta Penguin

I stopped reading when you put Dupuis in the same sentence as a 2 time 40 goal scorer

He is very good.

Just an FYI for others, he thinks a Derek Roy is way better than Jordan Staal.

Next ill be told how good Ennis and Hodgson are.
- Gunner Staal

I don't mind Hodgson actually. Not saying he's a cornerstone player but he's not bad. He'd fit in well on the Penguins among other teams.