Why is it ridicules? and I never mentioned Duby at all. Miller is a better player then Hemsky even though it's a different position.
- SABRES 89

Yes, Miller is a far better goalie then Hemsky is.

However, Hemsky is a way better RW.

So it evens out.

Why is it ridicules? and I never mentioned Duby at all. Miller is a better player then Hemsky even though it's a different position.
- SABRES 89

miller is abetter player than hemmer.
and worth marginally more. but not that much. maybe another 2nd or something.

the point was ridiculous as it has nothing to do with them not liking hemmer.
why does buffalo want to trade miller? cause he sucks?

it's actually an identical situation to miller/enroth for the most part.
two younger burgeoning star right wingers have made ales expendable

miller is abetter player than hemmer.
and worth marginally more. but not that much. maybe another 2nd or something.

the point was ridiculous as it has nothing to do with them not liking hemmer.
why does buffalo want to trade miller? cause he sucks?

it's actually an identical situation to miller/enroth for the most part.
two younger burgeoning star right wingers have made ales expendable
- hugefemale dog77

Our whole team sucks, it's not just 1 player.

miller is abetter player than hemmer.
and worth marginally more. but not that much. maybe another 2nd or something.

the point was ridiculous as it has nothing to do with them not liking hemmer.
why does buffalo want to trade miller? cause he sucks?

it's actually an identical situation to miller/enroth for the most part.
two younger burgeoning star right wingers have made ales expendable
- hugefemale dog77

It was taken out of context. Sabre 89 asked if Dubnyk was so great why would we trade him? Which I flipped and asked the same thing about Miller.

It was taken out of context. Sabre 89 asked if Dubnyk was so great why would we trade him? Which I flipped and asked the same thing about Miller.
- Dangles13

I never said anything about Dubnyk my comment was directed at Hemsky.

It was taken out of context. Sabre 89 asked if Dubnyk was so great why would we trade him? Which I flipped and asked the same thing about Miller.
- Dangles13

he was talking about hemsky, but your point still stands

Our whole team sucks, it's not just 1 player.
- SABRES 89

we have our fair share of players that I think the word 'suck' might apply.
but I don't think hemsky is one of em.
uber talented, frustrating, and fairly injury prone are more apt words to describe him imo

I never said anything about Dubnyk my comment was directed at Hemsky.
- SABRES 89

Sorry about that, my mistake. Either way a trade happens for two reasons. Two teams have needs to fill and find a dance partner, or a player wants out and demands a trade. I think this would be an example of filling needs.

I think a change for Miller would be good, also think that would bring back his elite status. Edmonton needs to start winning soon and Miller would be a good help towards. I like dubey but he's no Ryan Miller, yes Miller has had rough couple seasons but that was the team in general. I don't see buffalo taking Hemsky back no point for them as they are rebuilding and is why they want to trade Miller all he will do is help them draft in a worse position. I think it will be more like prospect, picks possibly dubynk going back.

we have our fair share of players that I think the word 'suck' might apply.
but I don't think hemsky is one of em.
uber talented, frustrating, and fairly injury prone are more apt words to describe him imo
- hugefemale dog77

Slacker

Sorry about that, my mistake. Either way a trade happens for two reasons. Two teams have needs to fill and find a dance partner, or a player wants out and demands a trade. I think this would be an example of filling needs.
- Dangles13

for sure.

in his case, there's a variety of reasons.

Sorry about that, my mistake. Either way a trade happens for two reasons. Two teams have needs to fill and find a dance partner, or a player wants out and demands a trade. I think this would be an example of filling needs.
- Dangles13

Would Drew Stafford fill any needs for your team? bathroom attendant? janitor?

Would Drew Stafford fill any needs for your team? bathroom attendant? janitor?
- SABRES 89

You mean he can't do both?

Would Drew Stafford fill any needs for your team? bathroom attendant? janitor?
- SABRES 89

drew Stafford 2010?? fuk yeah.
drew Stafford 2013? meh. prob not.

even if i would rather drew than hemsky best case.
but Id prob end up choosing to keep hemmer and let him walk at the end of the year than the extra year of staffords contract

Give us hemsky and some other bum with a high contract and we will dump money in ahl but throw in some picks.

You mean he can't do both?
- Dangles13

That's asking alot isn't it

That's asking alot isn't it
- SABRES 89

Fair enough, throw in John Scott and we've got a full custodial staff.

A good spot for Miller would be on the Island with Tavares. Solid young core where the only missing pieces are a number 1 goalie and a number 1 dman.

DD is one of the worst starters in the league, he sucks compared to RM

DD is one of the worst starters in the league, he sucks compared to RM
- PinkSock

Dubnyk is actually really good but whatever.

drew Stafford 2010?? fuk yeah.
drew Stafford 2013? meh. prob not.

even if i would rather drew than hemsky best case.
but Id prob end up choosing to keep hemmer and let him walk at the end of the year than the extra year of staffords contract
- hugefemale dog77

Stafford has good years in years that end in even numbers. Go for it

A good spot for Miller would be on the Island with Tavares. Solid young core where the only missing pieces are a number 1 goalie and a number 1 dman.
- Dangles13

Isn't that basically what Edmonton is missing as well?

Isn't that basically what Edmonton is missing as well?
- Yeti1181

I'm not convinced Dubnyk isn't the answer. He's just at the right age to hit his prime. New York doesn't haven that option in net.

And yet more 'reporting' from the "Yanked out of an engorged cows rear end department"

I'm all for sticking with the Big Easy this year. If he doesn't work out, address it next year. I think he will be a solid tender. MacT needs to address the teams size and D first.