some nhl redraft amongst the folks in here to be judged by bill.
- hammarby31

To be fair, Bill has yet to agree to judge.

Ah, I missed that, the 17-30 bit.

But okay. Let's use the 1993 Phillies as an example. Assuming they actually won that year, they were pretty awful in all of the surrounding years. So, come the 1995 draft, their records from 94, 92, 91, and 90 are going to far outweigh their one good year, and they could conceivably draft in the top 5.
- jmatchett383

Pretty much... the hockey equivalent would be the 'Canes... Cup bookended by consecutive seasons of missing the PO's... although the post-Cup Lavi 'Canes barely missed those years.

He seems to like it here. He talked about how good his experience with the organization was despite having his career nearly come to an end.
- PhillySportsGuy

they could each do a lot worse. i'd like to see him come back.

Our hockeybuzz fantasy draft. We have 7 people so far, we'd need 30.
- jmatchett383

I want all the Corsi players.

That happened anyway.
See: 2007 NHL Entry Draft
- jmatchett383

If the worst team could have dropped out of the top-5, my money would have been on the Flyers picking #6, lol.

Then again, that might have netted them Jake or Logan Couture.

Ah, I missed that, the 17-30 bit.

But okay. Let's use the 1993 Phillies as an example. Assuming they actually won that year, they were pretty awful in all of the surrounding years. So, come the 1995 draft, their records from 94, 92, 91, and 90 are going to far outweigh their one good year, and they could conceivably draft in the top 5.
- jmatchett383

I dont like it. Instead of stopping a team from tanking for 1 season to get a player, you have them tank for 4-5 seasons so they end up with 8-9 high draft picks.

Example year 1 of sucking they will have mid level pick
Year 2 will have a slightly lower pick
Year 3 Lower around top 5
Year 4 Top 5
Year 5 Top 5
Then they start to get better
Year 6 still top 5
Year 7 still top 5
Year 8 Likely top 10

they could each do a lot worse. i'd like to see him come back.
- hammarby31

I like Emery and would be happy if he came back. I would want someone on par with him backing up though. I don't want them to assume Heeter can do it or try to go with a cheap option like when they signed Leighton for last season. I want a legit backup. Someone who can play 20 games.

That happened anyway.
See: 2007 NHL Entry Draft
- jmatchett383

Thus the "..... "

some nhl redraft amongst the folks in here to be judged by bill.
- hammarby31

Bill hasnt committed to this BTW.

If the worst team could have dropped out of the top-5, my money would have been on the Flyers picking #6, lol.

Then again, that might have netted them Jake or Logan Couture.
- Tomahawk

Its not like they totally whiffed. It was just unlucky they missed out on Kane and it wasn't a very strong draft.

If the worst team could have dropped out of the top-5, my money would have been on the Flyers picking #6, lol.

Then again, that might have netted them Jake or Logan Couture.
- Tomahawk

Then who would we have got for Carter?

I like Emery and would be happy if he came back. I would want someone on par with him backing up though. I don't want them to assume Heeter can do it or try to go with a cheap option like when they signed Leighton for last season. I want a legit backup. Someone who can play 20 games.
- PhillySportsGuy

HALAK!

Then who would we have got for Carter?
- SchennBros

Zherdev and Couturier

Then who would we have got for Carter?
- SchennBros

Ryan Johansen?

Bill hasnt committed to this BTW.
- SchennBros

I think we'd need more than one judge anyway. We'd need a group. Basically, we need some form of evaluation.

Its not like they totally whiffed. It was just unlucky they missed out on Kane and it wasn't a very strong draft.
- PhillySportsGuy

Could have had Kane... Ended up with Luke Schenn......

HALAK!
- SchennBros

Halak may look for a place where he can fight for starting time. Wouldn't be surprised if he re-signed with Wash.

Bill hasnt committed to this BTW.
- SchennBros

everyone throw in $x or some other form of compensation. you can't ask the man to do it for free.

I think we'd need more than one judge anyway. We'd need a group. Basically, we need some form of evaluation.
- PhillySportsGuy

Point-shares?

http://www.hockey-referen...m/about/point_shares.html

I think we'd need more than one judge anyway. We'd need a group. Basically, we need some form of evaluation.
- PhillySportsGuy

How about we come together as GMs and vote for another person's team other then our own, and talley the votes.

How about we come together as GMs and vote for another person's team other then our own, and talley the votes.
- SchennBros

I don't appreciate your democracy.
Also, that leans towards personal bias (i.e. I'm picking whichever team has Shea Weber)

How about we come together as GMs and vote for another person's team other then our own, and talley the votes.
- SchennBros

I don't think that will work. Needs to be an unbiased entity.

I want all the Corsi players.
- wilsonecho91

do it, and you shall possess the Stanley Cup

I don't appreciate your democracy.
Also, that leans towards personal bias (i.e. I'm picking whichever team has Shea Weber)
- jmatchett383

*Shane Webber

Oh it's real.

I studied the poop outta the kidneys for my last physio exam
- Giroux_Is_God

And clearly didn't study hard enough if you think poop comes from kidneys!