Again, are we making fun of an actual issue I have to deal with in my actual life?
- Giroux_Is_God

That's (frank)ed up. It really is.

What exactly is this pissing match about anyways?

What exactly is this pissing match about anyways?
- Streit2ThePoint

Whether or not Hartnell is a "physical player" nowadays.

And, apparently, making fun of people's medical conditions.

Whether or not Hartnell is a "physical player" nowadays.

And, apparently, making fun of people's medical conditions.
- jmatchett383

Oh ok. Well he's still a physical player, maybe not as much in his earlier days, but he's still a physical presence on the ice.

How in the (frank) was that analogy irrelevant.
- Giroux_Is_God

Because it had zero to do with the debate, on Hartnell's physical play

Here is what happened here. Two different opinions were offered on Hartnell. Which is fine, because that's what were here for. To offer an opinion. Once the debate ensued, one side superschennbros offered evidence of both video and stats to support his opinion. You offered zero to support your opinion. And instead decided to compartmentalize his argument, down to one video, and attack that as not being enough of a sample size to make his point, and called it silly. And made an irrelevant analogy. Rather then actually countering his argument with evidence to support your view on the subject. It's pretty clear who made the better argument. Right or wrong in the conclusion. Which I happen to think he's right.

So, have we traded for Shea Weber yet?

The video was a (frank)ing satire
- Giroux_Is_God

No, the video was a poor counter argument and weak attempt to try and show a poster, who made a better argument than you did, that his argument was silly.

So, have we traded for Shea Weber yet?
- jmatchett383

Waiting on Cherry Hill's Bobby Ryan

Waiting on Cherry Hill's Bobby Ryan
- ob18

What do you think hometown discount. 5 years for 2.5M a year?

What do you think hometown discount. 5 years for 2.5M a year?
- MJL

That high? Heck, he should paying the Flyers to play for them.

What do you think hometown discount. 5 years for 2.5M a year?
- MJL

7 years or bust

So, have we traded for Shea Weber yet?
- jmatchett383

No but its rumored they are trading Rosehill for a new Weber grill.

No but its rumored they are trading Rosehill for a new Weber grill.
- BiggE

Does the grill have a NMC?

No but its rumored they are trading Rosehill for a new Weber grill.
- BiggE

How many burners on that grill?

What do you think hometown discount. 5 years for 2.5M a year?
- MJL

And free bowling at the Playdrome!

Folks, back off Giroux is God. First Giroux is god (though I didnt know god was a butt grabber). Second is climate point made sense as a way to describe a type of argument. Third, agree to disagree and move on. Harntell certainly has ( ). Although I am sad about as fan and in light of the character he brought to the team, Bill's Blog of yesterday helps me get over the sadness a bit.

No, the video was a poor counter argument and weak attempt to try and show a poster, who made a better argument than you did, that his argument was silly.
- MJL

In other words... a satire.

Folks, back off Giroux is God. First Giroux is god (though I didnt know god was a butt grabber). Second is climate point made sense as a way to describe a type of argument. Third, agree to disagree and move on. Harntell certainly has ( ). Although I am sad about as fan and in light of the character he brought to the team, Bill's Blog of yesterday helps me get over the sadness a bit.
- FlyersFirst

If Giroux isn't god, then why are some clouds shaped like butts?

So, have we traded for Shea Weber yet?
- jmatchett383

Yes. Still waiting for lebron to announce his decision before it's official though.

Because it had zero to do with the debate, on Hartnell's physical play

Here is what happened here. Two different opinions were offered on Hartnell. Which is fine, because that's what were here for. To offer an opinion. Once the debate ensued, one side superschennbros offered evidence of both video and stats to support his opinion. You offered zero to support your opinion. And instead decided to compartmentalize his argument, down to one video, and attack that as not being enough of a sample size to make his point, and called it silly. And made an irrelevant analogy. Rather then actually countering his argument with evidence to support your view on the subject. It's pretty clear who made the better argument. Right or wrong in the conclusion. Which I happen to think he's right.
- MJL

Good thing SSB didn't use advanced stats or his argument would have been invalid

Yes. Still waiting for lebron to announce his decision before it's official though.
- PhillySportsGuy

Aren't we tanking for McDavid or Eichel?

Aren't we tanking for McDavid or Eichel?
- ob18

Might as well tank for both. Tank to ensure we get 1st or 2nd overall, trade that immature brat Giroux and his buddy Voracek for the other pick.

Good thing SSB didn't use advanced stats or his argument would have been invalid
- PhillySportsGuy

Depends on how he used them. As always, advanced stats require context.

And one thing I'm still waiting on, is for any Corsi pundit to refute the issue of false data. But that's normally just ignored and glossed over. Just like the injury that Lecavalier had is sometimes ignored by those critical of Lecavalier as a player.

Might as well tank for both. Tank to ensure we get 1st or 2nd overall, trade that immature brat Giroux and his buddy Voracek for the other pick.
- jmatchett383

Correct.

Why stop at banishing just the one ginger Hartnell?

THEY ALL MUST GO!!

Does the grill have a NMC?
- jmatchett383

Well Holmgren was pushing for one, but Hextall overruled him