- Winning

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Pascal Dupuis diagnosed with blood clot in his lung; will be sidelined at least six months. Full release: pens.pe/1BNg1i2
- BulliesPhan87

The hell is up with the pens nowadays??

- Winning

embarrassing

You played for the Hawks?
- PLindbergh31

he didn't, but roenick did.

Huge difference. Dirk wad an established superstar, who took his game to a higher level. His overall level of play was closer to his playoff performance. Manning, is avg, played well during their 2 runs and got extremely lucky in crucial moments.....good for him

His best play was the pass to Buress. Cant take that away from him.......im just praying that an Eagle QB can do half of what Eli had done one day
- KINGKENZO

McNabb did about half of that.

But he has some stats that could be considered HOF. He has 3 (or 4) Cup rings and another SCF appearance. He's top-10 all time in wins, playoff wins, and playoff shutouts. If Eli gets in based on 2 supernatural drives, then Osgood should get in as well.
- jmatchett383

craig adams.

hall of famer.

he didn't, but roenick did.
- hammarby31

No way. I totally did. Played for them for 8 years and scored over 150 goals while sporting a better moustache than Parros.

But he has some stats that could be considered HOF. He has 3 (or 4) Cup rings and another SCF appearance. He's top-10 all time in wins, playoff wins, and playoff shutouts. If Eli gets in based on 2 supernatural drives, then Osgood should get in as well.
- jmatchett383

osgood should be a HOFer. this notion that his numbers and achievements are purely the product of the teams in front of him is absurd.

craig adams.

hall of famer.
- stayinthefnnet

Craig Adams shouldn't even be top 10 in in the category of "Current NHL players named Craig Adams."

embarrassing
- Crimsoninja

Ok. So 2 drives define his entire career? That makes him a HOFer?
- PhillySportsGuy

Is anyone making an argument that Eli should be a HOF?

McNabb did about half of that.
- jmatchett383

He should have done more......if he played as well as Eli did in his SB appearance. .....the Eagles would have won

osgood should be a HOFer. this notion that his numbers and achievements are purely the product of the teams in front of him is absurd.
- hammarby31

Agreed. Osgood gets underrated. He was a damned good goalie

No way. I totally did. Played for them for 8 years and scored over 150 goals while sporting a better moustache than Parros.
- jmatchett383

my mistake.

Craig Adams shouldn't even be top 10 in in the category of "Current NHL players named Craig Adams."
- jmatchett383

nah.

He as 2 cups.

The defense rests.

osgood should be a HOFer. this notion that his numbers and achievements are purely the product of the teams in front of him is absurd.
- hammarby31

Then how about Curtis Joseph? Has more wins, shutouts, and playoff shutouts than Osgood. Just played on teams that were never able to get a Cup.

He should have done more......if he played as well as Eli did in his SB appearance. .....the Eagles would have won
- KINGKENZO

Well, you just asked for half as good. McNabb was probably 70% as good.

He should have done more......if he played as well as Eli did in his SB appearance. .....the Eagles would have won
- KINGKENZO

he was busy not being able to run a 2 minute offense and vomiting.

Craig Adams shouldn't even be top 10 in in the category of "Current NHL players named Craig Adams."
- jmatchett383

to be fair, he is also the worst player in the NHL named craig adams.

But he has some stats that could be considered HOF. He has 3 (or 4) Cup rings and another SCF appearance. He's top-10 all time in wins, playoff wins, and playoff shutouts. If Eli gets in based on 2 supernatural drives, then Osgood should get in as well.
- jmatchett383

He does, but I just don't think he's on the level of goaltenders like Parent, Roy, Brodeur, and others that are in the HOF.
If I was voting, Manning wouldn't get in either.

nah.

He as 2 cups.

The defense rests.
- stayinthefnnet

He's right up there with superstars like Dustin Penner and Ruslan Fedotenko. Sadly, he can't touch mega stars like Kris Draper.

he was busy not being able to run a 2 minute offense and vomiting.
- hammarby31

to be continued


i have to head out for a while

nah.

He as 2 cups.

The defense rests.
- stayinthefnnet

(frank)in lawyers

He's a 4th liner, no more no less. He's probably better than VDV (not saying too much) but let's not jump on the TML castaways. It reeks of "all of the other players are better than all of our players" speak.
- jmatchett383

I think Frattin is a good skater and does have better skills. If it is an upgrade I think I do it.

He does, but I just don't think he's on the level of goaltenders like Parent, Roy, Brodeur, and others that are in the HOF.
If I was voting, Manning wouldn't get in either.
- MJL

Don't worry. Eli will not get in. Coughlin yes