Bradford should be the target if he's healthy.

His age fits


Eli is a dumpster fire throughout the season.
- dadeadhead

Eli's 3 pro bowls and 2 NFC championships in 5 different years disagree. Most recently 3 years ago. It ain't that far gone.

Bradford should be the target if he's healthy.

His age fits


Eli is a dumpster fire throughout the season.
- dadeadhead

With 2 Super bowl rings

With 2 Super bowl rings
- Maximum Signal

And MVPs I think.

Watch the wheels fall off of him too.
- dadeadhead

2 straight NFC championships and a Super Bowl.

I'll take Kaep over often injured porcelain Bradford that has never been to a Championship game let alone a winning record.

edit: if Bradford can stay healthy....if Bradford can stay healthy is the million dollar question.
Hasn't shown that he can.
I'll pass.

2 straight NFC championships and a Super Bowl.

I'll take Kaep over often injured porcelain Bradford that has never been to a Championship game let alone a winning record.
- BuffaloHardHat

I'll see you and max raise you.

Eli's 3 pro bowls and 2 NFC championships in 5 different years disagree. Most recently 3 years ago. It ain't that far gone.
- Der Kaiser

Eli has as many bad weeks throughout the season as good ones.

31-33 in the last 4 years.

Not interested in a 35 yr old QB.

Eli has as many bad weeks throughout the season as good ones.

31-33 in the last 4 years.

Not interested in a 35 yr old QB.
- dadeadhead

His w/l record says more about the team than the individual.

Like Ryan Miller.

Good Night! (Mic drop.)

With 2 Super bowl rings
- Maximum Signal

Another QB that'll get into the HOF because of it.


Closest he should get to it is when Peyton mentions him during his speech.


Sorry guy comes out has a good week followed by a 3 or 4 interception game way to much.

Watch the wheels fall off of him too.
- dadeadhead

They have already.

Although I'd would still take him over someone like Orton

Good Night! (Mic drop.)
- Der Kaiser

His w/l record says more about the team than the individual.

Like Ryan Miller.

Good Night! (Mic drop.)
- Der Kaiser

If you say so.

He's caused that team to lose as much as they've won.

Another QB that'll get into the HOF because of it.


Closest he should get to it is when Peyton mentions him during his speech.


Sorry guy comes out has a good week followed by a 3 or 4 interception game way to much.
- dadeadhead

He does, but in his defense the Giants have not had a good running attack in years.

Only the elite of the elite can single handedly carry a one dimensional team.

I would trust him here to take us to the playoffs

They have already.

Although I'd would still take him over someone like Orton
- sbroads24

IMO you'll see how much Kap misses his coach.

Eli has as many bad weeks throughout the season as good ones.

31-33 in the last 4 years.

Not interested in a 35 yr old QB.
- dadeadhead

Will be 34 in January

Has had 3 QB coaches last three years

The Giants were a tire fire

Coughlin's time has passed.

Family has good genes . His father and brother were both great quarterbacks after 34

If you say so.

He's caused that team to lose as much as they've won.
- dadeadhead

Like Ryan miller!

They have already.

Although I'd would still take him over someone like Orton
- sbroads24

The wheels fell of the entire organization almost at the onset of the season from the GM down.
Kaep, his 2 straight NFC Championships games and Super Bowl appearance in his less than 3 full season as a starting QB in the NFL...yea i think I'll take Kaep over anyone out there.

Will be 34 in January

Has had 3 QB coaches last three years

The Giants were a tire fire

Coughlin's time has passed.

Family has good genes . His father and brother were great quarterback after 34
- Maximum Signal

So when the season starts he'll be 4 months shy of 35. Like I said 35 year old QB.

And Archie didn't win a game past the age of 32. 0-10 33-35

Eli isn't Peyton.

The wheels fell of the entire organization almost at the onset of the season from the GM down.
Kaep, his 2 straight NFC Championships games and Super Bowl appearance in his less than 3 full season as a starting QB in the NFL...yea i think I'll take Kaep over anyone out there.
- BuffaloHardHat

I would be happy if we were to get him trust me. He's young and mobile with a strong arm. However he is coming off of a really bad season. He deserves some criticism for this past year

So when the season starts he'll be 4 months shy of 35. Like I said 35 year old QB.

And Archie didn't win a game past the age of 32. 0-10 33-35

Eli isn't Peyton.
- dadeadhead

I doubt the Giants trade him anyway.

So when the season starts he'll be 4 months shy of 35. Like I said 35 year old QB.

And Archie didn't win a game past the age of 32. 0-10 33-35

Eli isn't Peyton.
- dadeadhead

He turns 34 January 3

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eli_Manning

And Archie was on really bad teams.

Bradford is way to fragile and our O- line is a big question mark.

IMO you'll see how much Kap misses his coach.
- dadeadhead

Nah, he played poorly this season because that organization was set afire pretty much before the season even started.
His NFL career speaks for its self and it's a pretty loud one for just less than 3 full seasons as a starter but it's your opinion.
But I will say this , I don't know how anyone would want Bradford who has proven that he can't stay healthy and, who has never even had a winning record in the NFL over what Kaep has accomplished thus far.
Boggles my mind really.

Nah, he played poorly this season because that organization was set afire pretty much before the season even started.
His NFL career speaks for its self and it's a pretty loud one for just less than 3 full seasons as a starter but it's your opinion.
But I will say this , I don't know how anyone would want Bradford who has proven that he can't stay healthy and, who has never even had a winning record in the NFL over what Kaep has accomplished thus far.
Boggles my mind really.
- BuffaloHardHat

Kap is not going anywhere .

He turns 34 January 3

And Archie was on really bad teams.
- Maximum Signal

When the season starts he'll be almost 35(4 months shy).

Not interested in trading for a 35 yr old QB and then paying him 12 mil + over 4 years.

Nah, he played poorly this season because that organization was set afire pretty much before the season even started.
His NFL career speaks for its self and it's a pretty loud one for just less than 3 full seasons as a starter but it's your opinion.
But I will say this , I don't know how anyone would want Bradford who has proven that he can't stay healthy and, who has never even had a winning record in the NFL over what Kaep has accomplished thus far.
Boggles my mind really.
- BuffaloHardHat

I would rather have Kaepernick to be honest, because yes Bradford has a lot of injury issues and performance issues as well, but IMO Bradford is one of the only realistic options the Bills will have.

Kaepernick's contract is set up so the 49er's can cut him any year and they won't be stuck with a ton of dead money. I think they will give him more time

I would be happy if we were to get him trust me. He's young and mobile with a strong arm. However he is coming off of a really bad season. He deserves some criticism for this past year
- sbroads24

His bad season is attributed to the tire fire that was the entire San Francisco 49ers organization even before the season began.
Tons of instability right from the get go. You could see that the 49ers were not right coming out of the chute so to speak this season.