What a bunch of Bull Sh!t. Bieksa has no business being at #2. Hard to put him in the top 10 even..but he was here long enough to earn it I suppose.
- boonerbuck

sounds like a sympathy feck...

http://canucksarmy.com/2015/9/25/vancouver-canucks-top-10-best-defenseman-of-all-time

Bieksa at #2
- hillbillydeluxe

I call bull poop

sounds like a sympathy feck...
- hillbillydeluxe

I say take Bieksa out and put in Sbisa

I call bull poop
- VANTEL

I think he was very popular, but if he is listed among the best, it makes it look like the Canucks have never won a Stanley Cup or did that not happen?

I think he was very popular, but if he is listed among the best, it makes it look like the Canucks have never won a Stanley Cup or did that not happen?
- hillbillydeluxe

I can see him as one of the most popular. Maybe it was a fan vote

I say take Bieksa out and put in Sbisa
- VANTEL

Your late....
see last page..lol

http://canucksarmy.com/2015/9/25/vancouver-canucks-top-10-best-defenseman-of-all-time

Bieksa at #2
- hillbillydeluxe

That is so so wrong

I think the Canucks surprise and win a close 2-1 game tonight, revenge for the humilation of the 7-4 elimination game loss last year. Plus it's preseason and I don't see Calgary's first line going all out and potentially getting injured against Vancouver's lineup that's mostly of AHL-calibre talent and players looking to make an impression.

I can see him as one of the most popular. Maybe it was a fan vote
- VANTEL

Ohlund was pretty good though, I don't have an argument with him being #1. Just remember him and his clutch goals and fighting Iggy.

I think he was very popular, but if he is listed among the best, it makes it look like the Canucks have never won a Stanley Cup or did that not happen?
- hillbillydeluxe

I can see him being in the top ten. In his prime he was quite good and a physical deterrent

It is too bad Canucks did not send out an all youngster team to see what the future looks like

Sven Bo Grenier
Shink McCann JV
Gaunce Cassels Jensen
Stewart Vey Boeser

Hutton Pedan
Subban Cedarholm
Brisboise Sautner

Markstrom
Demko

It is too bad Canucks did not send out an all youngster team to see what the future looks like

Sven Bo Grenier
Shink McCann JV
Gaunce Cassels Jensen
Stewart Vey Boeser

Hutton Pedan
Subban Cedarholm
Brisboise Sautner

Markstrom
Demko
- VANTEL

I don't think playing all prospects gives you a good look. They need to see how they play with some experience around them... just like the real NHL.

I can see him being in the top ten. In his prime he was quite good and a physical deterrent
- Pres.cup

Snepsts was a bigger physical deterrent

Snepsts was a bigger physical deterrent
- A_SteamingLombardi

http://canucksarmy.com/2015/9/25/vancouver-canucks-top-10-best-defenseman-of-all-time

Bieksa at #2
- hillbillydeluxe

Pretty much bang on.

Snepsts was a bigger physical deterrent
- A_SteamingLombardi

Yes, but not as big or physical as Sbisa

- VANTEL

Aucoin, Halward, Lanz, McCarthy and Lindgren were all as good as Bieksa and yet they put him 2nd, this list was put together by an idiot.

Aucoin, Halward, Lanz, McCarthy and Lindgren were all as good as Bieksa and yet they put him 2nd, this list was put together by an idiot.
- A_SteamingLombardi

For me it's

Ohlund
Jovo
Harold
Salo
Mitchell
Lumme
Aucoin
Lidster
Hamhuis
Kearns

And a lot of love to Aaron Rome

For me it's

Ohlund
Jovo
Harold
Salo
Mitchell
Lumme
Aucoin
Lidster
Hamhuis
Kearns

And a lot of love to Aaron Rome
- VANTEL

Pat Quinn, Dale Tallon

Edit: they should do this list by each decade

Pat Quinn, Dale Tallon

Edit: they should do this list by each decade
- A_SteamingLombardi

I'm sure the list maker was tempted to just put Beiksa on the list only.

For me it's

Ohlund
Jovo
Harold
Salo
Mitchell
Lumme
Aucoin
Lidster
Hamhuis
Kearns

And a lot of love to Aaron Rome
- VANTEL

Aucoin in his prime better than Bieksa in his prime? I'm happy KB has moved on as well, but he was a good player in his day. Aucoin, not so much.

For me it's

Ohlund
Jovo
Harold
Salo
Mitchell
Lumme
Aucoin
Lidster
Hamhuis
Kearns

And a lot of love to Aaron Rome
- VANTEL

Loved those 2...that's when I first got into hockey.

http://canucksarmy.com/2015/9/25/vancouver-canucks-top-10-best-defenseman-of-all-time

Bieksa at #2
- hillbillydeluxe

No love for Babych's stache

Speaking of former Canucks defencemen I was surprised to see Doug Bodger as an alum at hockeyville...what was he a Canuck for 2 months?

Aucoin in his prime better than Bieksa in his prime? I'm happy KB has moved on as well, but he was a good player in his day. Aucoin, not so much.

- we_are_all_canucks

The only problem with this is you have to take the good with the bad. Sometimes the bad isn't the players fault, playing hurt and nobody else ready to step in.

But you do realize Aucoin had 23 goals in one of his seasons here...

Ehrhoff in the top ten...