You don't trade him for Weber unless there is some truth to it.
- Homer

You don't trade for Shea Weber....period. He's declining and signed until he's 40.

That deal is bad.

You don't trade him for Weber unless there is some truth to it.
- Homer

Yea you also dont trade Hall for Larsson, but that happened.

You don't trade for Shea Weber....period. He's declining and signed until he's 40.

That deal is bad.
- sbroads24

Agreed.

I do that deal everyday if I am Nashville.

I would love to see a gif of Montreal fans making fun of EDM for how dumb their trade was and then see the Breaking News headline on Subban.

It would be the ultimate crying Jordan moment.

Yea you also dont trade Hall for Larsson, but that happened.
- ImThatGuy

Now which trade is worse?

I still say Hall for Larsson is worse

Now which trade is worse?

I still say Hall for Larsson is worse
- Stripes77

Don't worry though, it will all make sense when we see what else the Oilers do, per EK.

Am I the only one who thinks that Subban for Weber is relatively even ? Now the oilers are a joke but Weber is fantastic and better defensively then Subban

You don't trade for Shea Weber....period. He's declining and signed until he's 40.

That deal is bad.
- sbroads24

We all know there are ways to get out of 'bad" contracts...and Weber is still very good.

I'm not saying its a good deal for Montreal but its not like its nearly as one sided as Hall for Larsson

Now which trade is worse?

I still say Hall for Larsson is worse
- Stripes77

They are both close to historically bad.

Subban might have beef with teammates, but he just donated 10 mil to a hospital.

It's not like he's getting into bar fights or being accused of being abusive

You don't trade for Shea Weber....period. He's declining and signed until he's 40.

That deal is bad.
- sbroads24

Nashville could have cap recapture issues with that contract in the future.

Am I the only one who thinks that Subban for Weber is relatively even ? Now the oilers are a joke but Weber is fantastic and better defensively then Subban
- Pegullaville

No you are not.

We all know there are ways to get out of 'bad" contracts...and Weber is still very good.

I'm not saying its a good deal for Montreal but its not like its nearly as one sided as Hall for Larsson
- Homer

I don't know man. Montreal literally just downgraded at the same position.

EDM at least....got a top 4 RD they desperately need

Both are so bad though.....

They are both close to historically bad.

Subban might have beef with teammates, but he just donated 10 mil to a hospital.

It's not like he's getting into bar fights or being accused of being abusive
- sbroads24

You had to go there didn't you

Who is this Stamkos guy? And what all the fuss about?

Now which trade is worse?

I still say Hall for Larsson is worse
- Stripes77

Much worse I agree, there I was expecting a couple firsts or at least a first and a second going back/players already drafted of that caliber...didn't happen.

Nashville should have had to swallow big time cap for making that trade and include more, but not nearly as egregious as EDM trading Hall away for Larsson.

Wouldn't Hall for Suban be the better deal?

Now which trade is worse?

I still say Hall for Larsson is worse
- Stripes77

+1

You had to go there didn't you
- Stripes77

I wonder who Nashville will name captain now

Wouldn't Hall for Suban be the better deal?
- gibby111

Montreal wanted the same position back.

I call "Collusion, Corruption, Old Boys Clubs"

You can't get away with this on NHL VideoGame!

1. Arizona "Gifts" Detroit 6.5 Million
2. Taylor Hall for F?cking Random NHL Dman
3. P. K. Subban for a 4-5 yr OLDER Shea Weber????

Somethings not smelling right in the kitchen!

Now which trade is worse?

I still say Hall for Larsson is worse
- Stripes77

Will someone please walk to bottoms up and drag tim murray out of there. Is he still partying with kane. How do you not get taylor hall. Adam larsson,really

I don't know man. Montreal literally just downgraded at the same position.

EDM at least....got a top 4 RD they desperately need

Both are so bad though.....
- sbroads24

Nashville might be paying 10.8 mil for subban

They possiblily have a 1.825 recapture penalty for moving Weber.

So if the Sabres would have won 6 more games last year they make the playoffs...

With Detroit not getting better, Boston and Montreal not getting better even if Price carrys them I see a way where Buffalo makes the playoffs with their roster as is right now...

Nashville might be paying 10.8 mil for subban

They possiblily have a 1.825 recapture penalty for moving Weber.
- dadeadhead

I just can't get over the age. Weber is declining and signed longer.

Makes no sense to me.

If they did Hall for Subban I could see it