Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Blog World :: Carol Schram: Vancouver Canucks lose Alex Edler for 4-6 weeks, Bo Horvat's comparables
Author Message
dbot
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Auckland -Burn it all down
Joined: 10.22.2008

Nov 28 @ 6:48 PM ET
How would everyone feel about a trade of

Tanev + JV + CBJ 2nd(or Subban + 3rd/4th) for Kane + Reinhart?

- Retinalz


Nope. I would not feel great about that.

I would only take Kane for cheap.
And tanev + jv is an overpayment for Reinhart.
If it was a 1st rounder from Buffalo....
As_I_See_It
Toronto Maple Leafs
Joined: 02.28.2011

Nov 28 @ 6:48 PM ET
Jake Gardiner would look great in a Canucks uniform
Retinalz
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Vancouver, BC
Joined: 01.31.2015

Nov 28 @ 6:48 PM ET
I think Kane is a dead horse when it comes to the Canucks.
- A_SteamingLombardi

hence why i am beating it
belcherbd
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Nanaimo
Joined: 02.16.2007

Nov 28 @ 6:48 PM ET
The point being, despite some clerical errors, drafting is definitely looking more promising. And just in time I might ad, given that we're entering a period of quality draft positions.
- LeftCoaster


I agree
neem55
Vancouver Canucks
Joined: 02.02.2012

Nov 28 @ 6:49 PM ET
Mixed...I think we should move on from Kane and trade a D for a quality forward prospect and a draft pick
- CanuckDon


I like this idea. Colorado has a few nice pieces. Rantanen would be an amazing pickup. There are a lot of teams that should/would want Tanev. Having Edler out 4-6 weeks means we will be losing. I wonder how Stecher will do with a different partner...
Marwood
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Cumberland, BC
Joined: 03.18.2010

Nov 28 @ 6:50 PM ET
In six drafts Gillis put ten players in at least one NHL game, of those ten only three are actively still playing in the NHL. In 2014 Benning put four players, Virtanen, McCann, Forsling & Tryamkin, in the league for at least a few games....think about that for a second!!

That's how bad our drafting has been. There should be a MINIMUM of six players playing from the Gillis draft years playing. Which is only one per year....pathetic.

And just for clarification Marwood, that's not hysterical posting, it's just translating, through words, what I'm reading for the sake of conversation

- LeftCoaster

Have you talked to your doctor about your blood pressure and the signs of heart disease?
Canada Cup
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Not here to sell jerseys , ON
Joined: 07.06.2007

Nov 28 @ 6:50 PM ET
I think Kane is a dead horse when it comes to the Canucks.
- A_SteamingLombardi



Kane's not that good. Skates down the wing and shoots wide. Rinse and repeat.
CanuckDon
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Las Vegas
Joined: 08.05.2014

Nov 28 @ 6:50 PM ET
Like I said I like Bo on the first unit ,I don't like the Twins and Edler on the first unit.

It is just time to give more responsibility to young guys like Stecher Bo Hutton Granlund

- VANTEL

WD would never remove the Sedin's from the first unit, although I agree it's worth a look. Bo, Sedin's, Loui and Stetcher is worth a try.
Retinalz
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Vancouver, BC
Joined: 01.31.2015

Nov 28 @ 6:51 PM ET
Jake Gardiner would look great in a Canucks uniform
- As_I_See_It

Sure, Gardiner + Nylander or Marner + a 3rd for Tanev.
LeftCoaster
San Jose Sharks
Location: Shark City, CA
Joined: 07.03.2009

Nov 28 @ 6:51 PM ET
Like I said I like Bo on the first unit ,I don't like the Twins and Edler on the first unit.

It is just time to give more responsibility to young guys like Stecher Bo Hutton Granlund

- VANTEL

Granlund on your first unit PP screams lottery pick, however, gotta deal with the hand your dealt as a coach.
belcherbd
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Nanaimo
Joined: 02.16.2007

Nov 28 @ 6:51 PM ET
Kane's not that good. Skates down the wing and shoots wide. Rinse and repeat.
- Canada Cup


I don't want kane, but his value for use would be his ability to play physical in our top 6 and get in on the fore check. I don't think anyone who is advocating for him here expect that he will solve our scoring woes.
LeftCoaster
San Jose Sharks
Location: Shark City, CA
Joined: 07.03.2009

Nov 28 @ 6:52 PM ET
Jake Gardiner would look great in a Canucks uniform
- As_I_See_It

He'd only look good in a James Tanner uniform, other than that he sucks.
dshiddy
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Canucks blogger in disguise., BC
Joined: 06.23.2008

Nov 28 @ 6:52 PM ET
Jake Gardiner would look great in a Canucks uniform
- As_I_See_It


Well he does look awful in a Leafs uniform.
CanuckDon
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Las Vegas
Joined: 08.05.2014

Nov 28 @ 6:52 PM ET
I like this idea. Colorado has a few nice pieces. Rantanen would be an amazing pickup. There are a lot of teams that should/would want Tanev. Having Edler out 4-6 weeks means we will be losing. I wonder how Stecher will do with a different partner...
- neem55

Colorado would be an interesting trade partner for Tanev. Although they wouldn't want Edler. Edler to a contender interests me the most.
Marwood
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Cumberland, BC
Joined: 03.18.2010

Nov 28 @ 6:53 PM ET
How would everyone feel about a trade of

Tanev + JV + CBJ 2nd(or Subban + 3rd/4th) for Kane + Reinhart?

- Retinalz

Violently ill.
Nuck4U
Vancouver Canucks
Location: NY
Joined: 10.12.2016

Nov 28 @ 6:53 PM ET
How would everyone feel about a trade of

Tanev + JV + CBJ 2nd(or Subban + 3rd/4th) for Kane + Reinhart?

- Retinalz


Tanev for Kane is an overpayment. Reinhart not being moved. If so straight swap no add ons. Then this market can make fun of him being too slow and small and wish they had JV back lol.
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Nov 28 @ 6:54 PM ET
WD would never remove the Sedin's from the first unit, although I agree it's worth a look. Bo, Sedin's, Loui and Stetcher is worth a try.
- CanuckDon



I think Willie is gone at the end of the year and The twins are gone after next year so it is better to start planning now for LAS (life after Sedins).

You got to start the transition sooner or later. Having your best player (Bo ) succeed is something that could save WD. Riding out the twins is a death sentence.
LeftCoaster
San Jose Sharks
Location: Shark City, CA
Joined: 07.03.2009

Nov 28 @ 6:54 PM ET
Have you talked to your doctor about your blood pressure and the signs of heart disease?
- Marwood

I had to take a physical for this latest posting....124/90 for a big man is good she told me.
Makita
Referee
Vancouver Canucks
Location: #theonlyrealfan, BC
Joined: 02.16.2007

Nov 28 @ 6:55 PM ET

*Yawn*
LeftCoaster
San Jose Sharks
Location: Shark City, CA
Joined: 07.03.2009

Nov 28 @ 6:55 PM ET
Well he does look awful in a Leafs uniform.
- dshiddy

Don't they all?
LeftCoaster
San Jose Sharks
Location: Shark City, CA
Joined: 07.03.2009

Nov 28 @ 6:56 PM ET
Violently ill.
- Marwood

Hysterics....calm down, it's only a proposal.
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Nov 28 @ 6:57 PM ET
Granlund on your first unit PP screams lottery pick, however, gotta deal with the hand your dealt as a coach.
- LeftCoaster



My first unit would be

Loui Bo Sutter
Hutton Stecher


Second unit

Danny Henrik Hansen
Edler Granlund

First unit 1.15 ice time second unit 45 seconds
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Nov 28 @ 6:58 PM ET
Colorado would be an interesting trade partner for Tanev. Although they wouldn't want Edler. Edler to a contender interests me the most.
- CanuckDon



Edler to ANA
LeftCoaster
San Jose Sharks
Location: Shark City, CA
Joined: 07.03.2009

Nov 28 @ 6:59 PM ET
Edler to ANA
- VANTEL

I said that a few days ago, good fit there IMO.
Retinalz
Vancouver Canucks
Location: Vancouver, BC
Joined: 01.31.2015

Nov 28 @ 6:59 PM ET
Edler to ANA
- VANTEL

Don't get my hopes up.
Page: Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18  Next