it's so funny the Ranger hatred around here, if Skjei was literally on any other team people would be freaking out about him
- jimbro83

it was two bloggers opinions...relax

I'm not saying he isn't good, just saying you are a little overzealous

i will make this simple for you. give me a list of players who shot 21% as an average for their career.
- Gramps28

I'll never bring up his 4 playoff goals again. They were 4 lucky shots. Never happen again.

it was two bloggers opinions...relax

I'm not saying he isn't good, just saying you are a little overzealous
- YuenglingJagr

its probably a good thing i didn't mention my opinion of McDonagh.

its probably a good thing i didn't mention my opinion of McDonagh.
- Gramps28

Whisper it into my ear.

I'll never bring up his 4 playoff goals again. They were 4 lucky shots. Never happen again.
- jimbro83

are you 12? there is a difference between saying his shooting % is unsustainable and an evaluation of his overall play. fyi. no one said he sucks. at this point Slavin IS better than Skjei based on any criteria you care to use. aside from being a fan of the team he plays on. As his Werenski. can it change? sure it can. IMO, Slavin and Werenski will always be the better players.

Whisper it into my ear.
- deadpoulet

over-rated.

its probably a good thing i didn't mention my opinion of McDonagh.
- Gramps28

Oh do tell gramps!

are you 12? there is a difference between saying his shooting % is unsustainable and an evaluation of his overall play. fyi. no one said he sucks. at this point Slavin IS better than Skjei based on any criteria you care to use. aside from being a fan of the team he plays on. As his Werenski. can it change? sure it can. IMO, Slavin and Werenski will always be the better players.
- Gramps28

Because you hate NY

over-rated.
- Gramps28

You just wrote it down on HB, but thanks.

1. Karlsson
2. Hedman
3. Letang
4.Faulk
5. Jones

McD is overrated.

Karlsson
Hedman
Weber
Ekblad
Jones
Carlson
McDonaugh
Rielly
Werenski
Ristolainen
Faulk
Gardiner
Hanifin
Slavin

Because you hate NY
- jimbro83

who doesn't?

You just wrote it down on HB, but thanks.
- deadpoulet

anytime chicken.

Karlsson
Hedman
Weber
Ekblad
Jones
Carlson
McDonaugh
Rielly
Werenski
Ristolainen
Faulk
Gardiner
Hanifin
Slavin
- mr.sir

I think McDonagh has beaten Carlson in the playoffs like 4000 times by now

You just wrote it down on HB, but thanks.
- deadpoulet

remember in the conference finals in 2014 when McDonagh had 10 points in 6 games.

oh yeah, remember Scott Gomez?

McD is overrated.
- Danformo

I think you meant under.
I'm not talking about this forum. I mean that you rarely hear his name when talking about top players. Personally, I don't know where he slots in. After Karlsson and Hedman I think there's a bunch of guys who are right there. But, I watch just about every NY game and I can say without bias that Mac does everthing at an elite level.

remember in the conference finals in 2014 when McDonagh had 10 points in 6 games.

oh yeah, remember Scott Gomez?
- jimbro83

I 'member Scott Gomez.

'Member Chewbacca?

1. Karlsson
2. Hedman
3. Letang (Oft injured but still one of the best)
4. Weber
5. Ekblad (Florida had a down year and so did Ekblad. Regardless, still top 5 in the East)
- Dannyboy

We have a winner.

Karlsson
Hedman
Weber
Ekblad
Jones
Carlson
McDonaugh
Rielly
Werenski
Ristolainen
Faulk
Gardiner
Hanifin
Slavin
- mr.sir

Hanifin has no business being on this list.

I think McDonagh has beaten Carlson in the playoffs like 4000 times by now
- jimbro83

3-2 can be rounded up to 4000 times, yes.

Karlsson
Hedman
Weber
Ekblad
Jones
Carlson
McDonaugh
Rielly
Werenski
Ristolainen
Faulk
Gardiner
Hanifin
Slavin
- mr.sir

What a garbage list. Hanifin? Ristolainen?
No Letang?

Praying for you.

How is Letang not mentioned at all?

Karlsson
Hedman
Letang
Weber
Krug/Werenski/Faulk

3-2 can be rounded up to 4000 times, yes.
- Blackstrom2

It's too bad McDonagh wasn't in that 2009 series. Because we'd have won and you really be wrong

Oh. Well then. I'm gonna have to watch more Carolina games.
- Wildschwein

Slavin is like their Klefbom.