HockeyBuzz Hotstove: Top-5 defensemen in the Eastern Conference?

ask me if I am willing to trade Ryan McDonagh for Torey Krug, go ahead ask

risto sucks, where's shattenkirk or buff?

Tessier, why or how do you know nothing about hockey..?

HockeyBuzz Hotstove: Top-5 defensemen in the Eastern Conference?
- ToddCordellVAN

Can't wait for the Western Conference version.

Peter Tessier

#1 Byfuglien

#2 Trouba

#3 Kulikov

#4 Myers

#5 Doughty

Tessier, why or how do you know nothing about hockey..?
- DARKSEID

That's like just your opinion man.

I think you do realize we are using a totally open set of criteria here and what I value may not be what Todd or others choose to value or use in determination.

risto sucks, where's shattenkirk or buff?
- Bigern4MVP

In the Western Conference?

Can't wait for the Western Conference version.

Peter Tessier

#1 Byfuglien

#2 Trouba

#3 Kulikov

#4 Myers

#5 Doughty
- eichiefs9

and then say the only reason the Jets never make the playoffs is because of goaltending

That's like just your opinion man.

I think you do realize we are using a totally open set of criteria here and what I value may not be what Todd or others choose to value or use in determination.
- Peter.Tessier

like blatantly hating the New York Rangers? is that one of your "criteria"?

Can't wait for the Western Conference version.

Peter Tessier

#1 Byfuglien

#2 Trouba

#3 Kulikov

#4 Myers

#5 Doughty
- eichiefs9

You got the order wrong! Get your game together there buddy!

like blatantly hating the New York Rangers? is that one of your "criteria"?
- jimbro83

Todd hates them too!

Damn, late again.

1. Karlsson
2. Hedman
3. McDunugh
4. Shattenkirk
5. Gardiner

Risto is a dumpster fire.

You got the order wrong! Get your game together there buddy!
- Peter.Tessier

I'm sorry, you may not have heard but my wife, lminda, left me

1. Victor Hedman
2. Zach Werenski
3. Ryan McDonagh
4. Erik Karlsson
5. John Carlson

Honorable Mentions: Seth Jones; Matt Niskanen

Dishonorable Mention: Peter Tessier

Damn, late again.

1. Karlsson
2. Hedman
3. McDunugh
4. Shattenkirk
5. Gardiner
- james_tanner1

Oh ok.

1. Victor Hedman
2. Zach Werenski
3. Ryan McDonagh
4. Erik Karlsson
5. John Carlson

Honorable Mentions: Seth Jones; Matt Niskanen

Dishonorable Mention: Peter Tessier
- DARKSEID

Niskanen >> Carlson.

That's like just your opinion man.

I think you do realize we are using a totally open set of criteria here and what I value may not be what Todd or others choose to value or use in determination.
- Peter.Tessier

What is your criteria, though? Nothing?

Niskanen >> Carlson.
- Blackstrom2

I have seen you post this before. Agree to disagree.

First: Andrew MacDonald
Last: Andrew MacDonald

it's very unpopular to say it, I realize it, but Shea Weber is one of the top 5 defensemen in east

1. Victor Hedman
2. Zach Werenski
3. Ryan McDonagh
4. Erik Karlsson
5. John Carlson

Honorable Mentions: Seth Jones; Matt Niskanen

Dishonorable Mention: Peter Tessier
- DARKSEID

LOL- thanks for coming out.

What is your criteria, though? Nothing?
- DARKSEID

What's yours? A Ranger must be on the list?

What's yours? A Ranger must be on the list?
- Peter.Tessier

yeah, because the ONLY reason the Ranger are ever good is because of Lundqvist.

Then when these lists come out for goalies lets leave Lundqvist off too

it's very unpopular to say it, I realize it, but Shea Weber is one of the top 5 defensemen in east
- jimbro83

also a little early to be putting jones in the top 5, let alone werenski.

1. hedman
2. karlsson
3. mcdonagh
4. carlson
5. weber