Guess it depends on the guy they get in return.
- BashCH

for a 3rd liner who scored 2 goals?
yeah, that should bring a top 4 dman no doubt

for a 3rd liner who scored 2 goals?
yeah, that should bring a top 4 dman no doubt
- fidopro

He's a good young prospect. He'll keep improving.

for a 3rd liner who scored 2 goals?
yeah, that should bring a top 4 dman no doubt
- fidopro

Fans fall in love with their players and overvalue them.

He's a good young prospect. He'll keep improving.
- BashCH

Not a prospect anymore. He's been in the NHL for a while now.

He's a good young prospect. He'll keep improving.
- BashCH

oh sure, but for now they wouldn't get more than a Schlemco type of d in return
keep him.

I'm far from sure. It's not like he is breaking anything in Montreal.

By the way, when I proposed to go after a ufa this summer, you were against it and same with getting a young defenseman.

Not doing anything and expecting that defense to get better is a joke.

They never replaced Markov and did not have a plan for it.
- deadpoulet

When did I say they shouldn't trade for a young D?? Cause all I've been saying is they should trade for a young D...

Danault & a 3rd to LA for Kale Clague or a package for Ty Smith or Jett Woo (who's Josh Brook's D partner in Moose Jaw)... those are guys they should be targeting... Jake Bean, Dante Fabbro....

Then what do you propose? Any names for names in mind?
- deadpoulet

Just listed 4-5 of them, there's plenty more... or you could do some research, right? 😉

Not a prospect anymore. He's been in the NHL for a while now.
- deadpoulet

No, he's not a prospect... how about seeing what they have in Mete, Reilly, Juulsen and Ouellet instead of scratching them in favor of Alzner, Schlemko and Benn? That would be a start...

When did I say they shouldn't trade for a young D?? Cause all I've been saying is they should trade for a young D...

Danault & a 3rd to LA for Kale Clague or a package for Ty Smith or Jett Woo (who's Josh Brook's D partner in Moose Jaw)... those are guys they should be targeting... Jake Bean, Dante Fabbro....
- obie

A package of poop is not gonna give you more than poop. That's why you think I want to give too much. You come up with the famous package of poop from the fans too scare to do anything.

A package of poop is not gonna give you more than poop. That's why you think I want to give too much. You come up with the famous package of poop from the fans too scare to do anything.
- deadpoulet

Well if were talking Smith or Woo... I'd be willing to part with quite a bit....

How about Tatar? He could bring back a D

... here comes the hate 😁

No, he's not a prospect... how about seeing what they have in Mete, Reilly, Juulsen and Ouellet instead of scratching them in favor of Alzner, Schlemko and Benn? That would be a start...
- obie

Well Juulsen is hurt. Most of the guys are on and off.

Sure, I would prefer them to the 3 amigos, but I don't see them as a partner for Weber, a guy who by the way, did not play in 1 year.

Well if were talking Smith or Woo... I'd be willing to part with quite a bit....

How about Tatar? He could bring back a D

... here comes the hate 😁
- obie

Tomasssss Taaaaahtaaaaaar!!!

Coyotes
- AdamFrench

Bad trade is bad.

Well if were talking Smith or Woo... I'd be willing to part with quite a bit....

How about Tatar? He could bring back a D

... here comes the hate 😁
- obie

If they really wanted Woo, they would've drafted him last summer...

No. Petry sucks.

- Pete26 + Fred
- hscesq

75% of the time

Well Juulsen is hurt. Most of the guys are on and off.

Sure, I would prefer them to the 3 amigos, but I don't see them as a partner for Weber, a guy who by the way, did not play in 1 year.
- deadpoulet

The question is : are we building for the future or frantic to make the playoffs?

The question is : are we building for the future or frantic to make the playoffs?
- Fredo

I'm afraid now that they've played well Bergevin will just trade all his assets to make the playoffs and lose in 4 games.

If they really wanted Woo, they would've drafted him last summer...
- BashCH

They probably wanted every guy in the 1st round, you only get to draft 1, doesn't mean you have no interest in all the other ones, does it?

Tomasssss Taaaaahtaaaaaar!!!
- Snots33_77

I love the guy but if a playoff team needing offense is willing to part with a good young D for him, I'll pack his bags myself

Well Juulsen is hurt. Most of the guys are on and off.

Sure, I would prefer them to the 3 amigos, but I don't see them as a partner for Weber, a guy who by the way, did not play in 1 year.
- deadpoulet

Juulsen is hurt now but he too fell victim to Julien's incompetence earlier this year

I love the guy but if a playoff team needing offense is willing to part with a good young D for him, I'll pack his bags myself
- obie

It was a wicked one timer agaisnt the Bruins man

The question is : are we building for the future or frantic to make the playoffs?
- Fredo

If there is a chance at the playoffs near the deadline, Bergevin will most likely do something. It's a business fox.

It was a wicked one timer agaisnt the Bruins man
- Fredo

No doubt.... The guy is a player, top 6 F on any team... but like I said, if a team offers up a young D prospect for him, you have to pull the trigger

If there is a chance at the playoffs near the deadline, Bergevin will most likely do something. It's a business fox.
- deadpoulet

Still a long way from now.

Should he look for a partner for Weber now or give Reilly and Mete a shot?

Still a long way from now.

Should he look for a partner for Weber now or give Reilly and Mete a shot?
- Fredo

I'd go with the latter