call iy what yoi will you still havent presented any logical reasoning why the blues should be higher
- billneftleberg

If you cant see the extremely obvious holes in your argument, then you're a lost cause dude.

Putting together the 6 best players in a franchise's history(most of whom likely all played for said franchise at different times) doesnt correlate in any way with championships. As I said if youre ignorant enough to think they do, then there is really no point in continuing discussing this.

In all reality there is no point any way because this list is (frank)ing awful and makes no sense as Ek just makes poop up as he goes, much like all of his "rumors".

The Oilers won NBA titles too?
- gergeswillems

kevin durant is joining them next year

call it what you will, you still havent presented any logical reasoning why the blues should be higher

all you present are over the hill veterans who did their winning for other teams

none of them ever won anything as blues

federenko great blue,same with Parayko, tarasenko and Pieterangelo,and tkachuk and I loved red berenson, but they never won anything
- billneftleberg

name another team thats been around as long as the blues who have never won squat

for colorado you left out Milan Hejduk, with Sakic and Forsberg they should be top 10 at least

name another team thats been around as long as the blues who have never won squat
- billneftleberg

Leafs.

kevin durant is joining them next year
- DeflatedPucks

except youre trying and failing to see none of those players were elite as blues so youre trying to to say you can put a great team together. you cant because as blues they were over the hill

the gretzky the blues had wasnt the same as the oiler gretzky same with jagr and Macinnis they were shadows of who they used to be as blues and you know it

Leafs.
- gergeswillems

wrong the leafs have 4 titles do they not, they havent won since 67 but they have woni said nane a team thats been around as long as the blue and hasnt won. there are two but they arent whining about their ranking

wrong the leafs have 4 titles do they not, they havent won since 67 but they have woni said nane a team thats been around as long as the blue and hasnt won. there are two but they arent whining about their ranking
- billneftleberg

Moving the goal posts are we? Since the Blues have been in existence how many Cups have the Leafs won exactly? Can you tell me those years? Or is your math just as flawed as your English?

wrong the leafs have 4 titles do they not, they havent won since 67 but they have woni said nane a team thats been around as long as the blue and hasnt won. there are two but they arent whining about their ranking
- billneftleberg

The Leafs have 4 titles? Do the other 9 not count?

The Leafs have 4 titles? Do the other 9 not count?
- gergeswillems

Not to this retard apparently.

name another team thats been around as long as the blues who have never won squat
- billneftleberg

Neftleberg. That's a pretty decent hockey name!

wings canadiens and edmonton are my top 3. interchangeable on who is 1-3.

wings canadiens and edmonton are my top 3. interchangeable on who is 1-3.
- wingz4life

This. But Alfie thinks Ottawa has it, so our opinion is crap.

I know they had Marty and all, but the Devils seem rather high

I'm pretty sure the Barasso will hold the record for most wins as an 18yr old for quite a while. Plus he was LEFT HANDED!

I know they had Marty and all, but the Devils seem rather high
- Hesh_

agree. forwards are lacking.

This. But Alfie thinks Ottawa has it, so our opinion is crap.
- RafiDRW

Yeah but when he did his rankings Chabot was playing in the AHL.

Everyone getting worked up over these lists needs to understand Ek has watched hockey for <20 years and has the hockey IQ of a potato.

agree. forwards are lacking.
- wingz4life

they are terrible. That wouldn't be an NHL 1st line on a contending team without the 3 playing behind them.

Everyone getting worked up over these lists needs to understand Ek has watched hockey for <20 years and has the hockey IQ of a potato.
- muffin_man

Yes.

Giroux might have been worth a mention over Barber. I know Barber is 2nd all time for points in Philly, but Claude is poised to pass him in a little more than 2 years

Pavel Kubina before Dan Boyle?

The Blues lose points for Bob "The Bleeder" Bassen, Craig Janney's wife, and Imo's Pizza.

The Blues lose points for Bob "The Bleeder" Bassen, Craig Janney's wife, and Imo's Pizza.
- BaronVonShiznit[/quote]


Ive never met a pizza i wouldnt eat.....until I came across this cracker-crusted puke-cheese covered travesty

IMHO you are giving Pronger too much credit for his overall career as a Flyer. I would put, for overall impact on the team I would lean towards Eric Desjardins.