Binnington will win the calder....book it.
- Makita

That’s another troll. That’s two in a week.

Three strikes you’re out. Last warning.

Binnington is the most valuable rookie to his team ... Pete was the most outstanding overall ...
- Redmile247

Johnny Gaudreau

Johnny Gaudreau
- CanuckDon

Good comparable ...both kinda disappeared last couple months ...

Binnington is the most valuable rookie to his team ... Pete was the most outstanding overall ...
- Redmile247

Most valuable rookie? I don’t know. I would argue that Binnington is the Blues most valuable player regardless if he’s a rookie or not. Doesn’t make his season more impressive than Pete’s imo.

Most valuable rookie? I don’t know. I would argue that Binnington is the Blues most valuable player regardless if he’s a rookie or not. Doesn’t make his season more impressive than Pete’s imo.
- bloatedmosquito

I think Pete wins for sure ...if Binnington was 4 years younger and played 10-15 more games ...then we have more of a race

That’s another troll. That’s two in a week.

Three strikes you’re out. Last warning.
- bloatedmosquito

just getting my cynical side prepared for a Vancouver screw over again..


Edit: I forget the first one, I’m just such a prolific poster I can’t keep track?

I think Pete wins for sure ...if Binnington was 4 years younger and played 10-15 more games ...then we have more of a race
- Redmile247

Understood and agree.

I’m not a fan of having rookie goalies and players competing for the same trophy. It’s a difficult comparison to make. Their impacts are so different to a team. For me, I see a goalie’s impact similar to quarterbacks, pitchers, etc.

just getting my cynical side prepared for a Vancouver screw over again..


Edit: I forget the first one, I’m just such a prolific poster I can’t keep track?
- Makita

Does Pez Mike Gillis ring a bell?

Does Pez Mike Gillis ring a bell?
- bloatedmosquito

All Gillis needs is a dinner with Aquilini and it's a done deal.

All Gillis needs is a dinner with Aquilini and it's a done deal.
- A_SteamingLombardi

Not so fast, I think Gillis has to pay for dinner.

Not so fast, I think Gillis has to pay for dinner.
- golfingsince

The last time they had dinner we all paid.

Not so fast, I think Gillis has to pay for dinner.
- golfingsince

That's Ok. Anton's is reasonable and will even let Aquaman bring home a doggy bag!

Does Pez Mike Gillis ring a bell?
- bloatedmosquito

That wasn’t trolling, I even provided the province story link

I was just as shocked as you that Aquilini would even consider something so bloody stupid

The last time they had dinner we all paid.
- A_SteamingLombardi

That's Ok. Anton's is reasonable and will even let Aquaman bring home a doggy bag!
- Shuswap Wap

Antons is my bros place. I'll see if he can poison dart FA while they're getting seated.
All of you would owe me big time

That wasn’t trolling, I even provided the province story link

I was just as shocked as you that Aquilini would even consider something so bloody stupid
- Makita

Fair enough, but accessory to trolling is still trolling. Or linking a Province story is equal to peddling smut. Have your pick; troll or smut-monger?

The last time they had dinner we all paid.
- A_SteamingLombardi

zinger.

Most valuable rookie? I don’t know. I would argue that Binnington is the Blues most valuable player regardless if he’s a rookie or not. Doesn’t make his season more impressive than Pete’s imo.
- bloatedmosquito

As impressive as Binnington has been he only played 20 regular season games? Not sure how he even got into Calder voting but is what it is. If the League gives it to him over Petey wow...that's worse than Gary having his refs apologize to Vegas

As impressive as Binnington has been he only played 20 regular season games? Not sure how he even got into Calder voting but is what it is. If the League gives it to him over Petey wow...that's worse than Gary having his refs apologize to Vegas
- LordHumungous

Bettmanhatesus, is that you?

He played 32, with these stats:

GP W L OT GAA Sv%
32 24 5 1 1.89 .927

I don’t think he should win based on sample size, but those are fantastic stats for a goalie... especially since the Blues turn around started when he came up.

Bettmanhatesus, is that you?

He played 32, with these stats:

GP W L OT GAA Sv%
32 24 5 1 1.89 .927

I don’t think he should win based on sample size, but those are fantastic stats for a goalie... especially since the Blues turn around started when he came up.
- NewYorkNuck

lol ok wasn't sure how many he played but knew it wasn't lots.

Ya agree too small sample size to win but impressive numbers none the less.

Bettmanhatesus, is that you?

He played 32, with these stats:

GP W L OT GAA Sv%
32 24 5 1 1.89 .927

I don’t think he should win based on sample size, but those are fantastic stats for a goalie... especially since the Blues turn around started when he came up.
- NewYorkNuck

Sample size has continued into the playoffs where it counts. I want Petey to win but Binnington is going to win it.

The biggest knock against Binnington is he is 25 and been playing in a professional league 6 years.

Sample size has continued into the playoffs where it counts. I want Petey to win but Binnington is going to win it.

The biggest knock against Binnington is he is 25 and been playing in a professional league 6 years.
- thundachunk

I don’t think that’s correct...

The winner is selected in a poll of the Professional Hockey Writers' Association at the end of the regular season and each individual voter ranks their top five candidates on a 10 -7-5-3-1 points system. Three finalists are named and the trophy is awarded at the NHL Awards ceremony after the playoffs.

Sample size has continued into the playoffs where it counts. I want Petey to win but Binnington is going to win it.

The biggest knock against Binnington is he is 25 and been playing in a professional league 6 years.
- thundachunk

Playoffs should have absolutely nothing to do with the award. But that's the mentality.

They gave the Hart to Hall when it should have went to McDavid...just because Jersey made the PO's then got torched.

I think Pete wins for sure ...if Binnington was 4 years younger and played 10-15 more games ...then we have more of a race
- Redmile247

Playoffs should have absolutely nothing to do with the award. But that's the mentality.

They gave the Hart to Hall when it should have went to McDavid...just because Jersey made the PO's then got torched.
- LordHumungous

The votes have already been sent in , haven't they?