Exactly, the logic is ridiculous
- Dozzer

Speaking of ridiculous logic, you got your badge back?

Ok, so where do you draw the line? When, in your opinion, can a player be considered a viable piece to a contender when they haven’t done so yet? Honest question... where’s that line?
- Dozzer

are we really going to continue this?

justin holl has played 13 games as a forward and 62 games as an nhl defenseman at the age of 28.

he's not even a proven quality nhl defenseman yet. he's a plug.

Lost? not a single person here agrees with your logic and I lost?

And “bro”? oh god you’re one of those
- Dozzer

it's all super homer leaf fans, can you really expect anything less?

Imagine our situation if Dubas traded Barrie for picks? LOL. We'd be screwed

new blog everyone

Exactly, the logic is ridiculous
- Dozzer

the logic you fabricated, you mean.

holl is not an experienced nhl player, there is a difference between an experienced nhl player and one that has 60 games under his belt at age 28.

an experienced guy who has a rep as a solid player, a guy like holl is an enigma, he hasn't even played any playoff games so how can he be looked at as a key or viable piece to a cup contender?

ekblad on the other hand was a #1 overall pick who is far more talented than holl and also has nhl experience, he is 24 years old and already in his 6th season in the league. he has also played in at least 1 playoff round. since he is far and away a superior talent to holl, it is with ease that you can say ekblad would be a viable key piece to a true cup contending team unlike justin holl and his 60 games nhl experience at age 28.

you guys have interpreted everything that i have said incorrectly, almost like by design just to argue over something so obvious.

It was insane in here last night.

All rookie team of defenders (plus Barrie, not exactly a stalwart defender) managed to hold on for a good win where we kept the shots fairly low and the Downer Patrol thought we should have more shots, wasn't good enough, and Holl is overpaid
- gravyface

i never said holl was overpaid, i don't recall anybody saying that to be honest.