Sportsnet ran a "what if" Gretzky signed with the Leafs for the 96/97 season story the other day. It's an interesting question so I dusted off the most state of the art NHL simulator at the time...NHL 97 (the one with John Vanbiesbrouck on the cover) for the SNES (actually a RetroDuo that plays NES and SNES games) and inserted Gretzky into the 96/97 Leafs.
Simulated the season. Results? Dead last in the division. Oddly enough, Bryan McCabe led the NHL with 40 goals.
So I ran a different kind of "what if" scenario. What if the Leafs got to re-do all their 1st and 2nd round picks from 1981 to 1991.
1981
Benning 6th ---> MacInnis 15th.
Yaremchuk 24th ---> Chelios 40th.
1982
Nylund 3rd ---> Stevens 5th.
Leeman 24th ---> Same and trade for Gilmour or just pick Gilmour.
Ihnacak 25th ---> Sandstrom 36th.
1983
Courtnall 7th ---> Neely 9th.
Jackson 28th ---> Zezel 41st.
1984
Iafrate 4th ---> Roberts 12th.
Gill 25th ---> Same.
1985
Clark 1st ---> Same.
Spangler 22nd ---> Nieuwendyk 27th.
1986
Damphousse 6th ---> Same.
But traded for Shanahan
1987
Richardson 7th ---> Sakic 15th.
Marois 28th ---> Desjardins 38th.
1988
Pearson 6th ---> Selanne 10th. (Roenick at 8th or Brind'Amour at 9th)
Domi 27th ---> Same.
1989
Thornton 3rd ---> Guerin 5th.
Pearson 12th ---> Kolzig 19th.
Guerin + Kolzig ---> Sundin.
Bancroft 21st ---> Foote 22nd.
1990
Berehowsky 10th ---> Brodeur 20th.
Potvin 31st ---> Same.
1991
Niedermayer 3rd ---> Same.
So here's how the 1992-1997 Leafs could have looked.
Shanahan / Sakic / Sundin
Clark / Gilmour / Selanne
Roberts / Nieuwendyk / Neely
Sandstrom / Zezel / Domi
Stevens / Chelios
Niedermayer / MacInnis
Foote / Desjardins
Gill
Brodeur
Potvin
Simulated the entire season 96/97 season and this time the Leafs finished 1st in the Division, 3rd overall.
Awards:
Presidents Trophy: Flyers
Vezina: Cujo
Jennings: Hextall
Norris: Desjardins
All realistic scenarios in 1996/1997. Then poop got weird.
Art Ross: Renberg
Selke: Renberg
Yes, THE Mikael Renberg.
But wait...there's more!
Lester B. Pearson: Janney
Hart: Janney
Yes, THE Craig Janney.
He had 79 points (12th overall) but he was double MVP.
On to the playoffs. Simulated every game except elimination games.
1st round: Phoenix: 4-0.
2nd round: Colorado: 4-0.
3rd round: Dallas: 4-3. Game 7 OT GWG: Roberts.
Final: Florida: 4-0. Cup winning goal at Maple Leaf Gardens: Clark.
One last award...
Conn Smythe: Svehla
Yes, THE Robert Svehla.
But Leafs win!