To me Ottawa is being far too generous in this proposal. They are likely moving BACK in this years draft, taking two bad contracts from St. Louis and only getting a likely 20-30 pick in next years draft in return. All of this would basically allow St. Louis to keep Pieterangelo, so you can almost add that in to St. Louis' return.
A comparable to how this should be structured would be the Marleau trade last year. TML gave up their 1st and 7th to shed the contract of Marleau, and got a 6th in return.
Ottawa should not be giving up their first in this trade. Taking St. Louis' 1st this year with Steen and Allen for a 7th is more reasonable, if they could get next year's first or a decent prospect as well, even better. St. Louis is not in a good bargaining position.
- flyer4ever75
Hmmm. I can see where you are coming from.
Allen could be a serviceable replacement and give Ottawa a year to see what he is. I don’t see that as a cap dump primarily.
Steen is 36 and only has one more year at 5.25M to which I still could see him as a bottom-6 roster player, a great influence on the young bucks on the ice and as a professional outside of the rink.
You could decipher this as a cap dump. The main difference I think between Marleau and Steen+Allen is that Toronto should have just bought Marleau out themselves and used their 1st to continue adding young pieces to their young core. To this day I believe Carolina got a very lopsided trade taking on Marleau and essentially getting a very high draft pick in an extremely deep draft.
St Louis has been trading and extending top-4 defensemen in an attempt to replace what Pietrangelo brought to the table. Essentially Armstrong has accepted that Alex wants to flex his UFA rights and doesn’t want to stay in St Louis.
I will say this - before I posted the offer I figured that a 2020 or 2021 3rd would be added to make things fair, however, took it away as I realized that both players being acquired were one year away from free agency.
My revised offer would be this;
To Ottawa
Steen
Allen
2020 1st - STL
2021 1st - STL
Kostin
To St Louis
Nilsson
2020 1st - NYI