This disappoints me if true. Based on some analytical readings, it might be time to cut bait if he has value. If he doesn't have value, I'd rather just see if he gets it.

Bet gerbe is filling his shorts thinking about trading Fattelstadt.
- TheSabresTaco

That's what happens when you have a double chin For 4 years

It's funny how anything brought up on here isn't good enough. Everyone is crying about getting a 2C but when one is brought up, oh its not good enough or the price is to much. Monahan would be the 3rd or 4th best player on are team.

Mitts is to small and we are in a division that is big and and has grit, we have none of that
- SABRES 89

Hopefully Sam Bennett's coming back

You wanna pay for Sean monahan who doesn't know a lick of defense only has produced With Johnny hockey one of the top wingers in the nhl and will not be with him ...

Got it

I'm not giving up the 8th when The player at 8th will be better
- gerbe75pts

WAIT NOW WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT DEFENSE.

THIS WAS NOT BROUGHT UP UNTIL NOW.

60-70 point center, yea i'm good with that. IS that not what you want your 8th overall pick to become?

Obviously id want anotehr piece but i wouldnt be overly mad if if was 1 for 1.
- ImThatGuy

Sure. But also 7 years older. Don't have enough time to debate the merits, but I think there's pros and cons here.

I personally would send the pick away for the right player to make us better right now. Monahan and a 2nd or a top 6 winger would be brilliant.

It's funny how anything brought up on here isn't good enough. Everyone is crying about getting a 2C but when one is brought up, oh its not good enough or the price is to much. Monahan would be the 3rd or 4th best player on are team.
- Buff36

But his defense would kill us that's the problem if you're paying little for him fine not the 8th overall pick

It's funny how anything brought up on here isn't good enough. Everyone is crying about getting a 2C but when one is brought up, oh its not good enough or the price is to much. Monahan would be the 3rd or 4th best player on are team.
- Buff36

Yea but he played with other good players, so hes not as good as the other good players, or something.

That's what happens when you have a double chin For 4 years
- gerbe75pts

Fat guy fetishes?

It's funny how anything brought up on here isn't good enough. Everyone is crying about getting a 2C but when one is brought up, oh its not good enough or the price is to much. Monahan would be the 3rd or 4th best player on are team.
- Buff36

I'm on board.

Bring him in!

- TheSabresTaco

A+

WAIT NOW WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT DEFENSE.

THIS WAS NOT BROUGHT UP UNTIL NOW.
- ImThatGuy

Everyone know Sean monahan is Brain dead when it comes to defense

Everyone know Sean monahan is Brain dead when it comes to defense
- gerbe75pts

What is ALex Ovechkin then....

Fat guy fetishes?
- TheSabresTaco

More like waste of talent fetish

Everyone know Sean monahan is Brain dead when it comes to defense
- gerbe75pts

He will see less top matchups which should help him. Eichel will shelter him.

MAKE THE TRADE, ADAMS!

What is ALex Ovechkin then....
- ImThatGuy

Better

He will see less top matchups which should help him. Eichel will shelter him.

MAKE THE TRADE, ADAMS!
- Powerslave

Not for the 8th overall pick that's a rip off

Not for the 8th overall pick that's a rip off
- gerbe75pts

If that's the deal, you're going to have to come to terms with it.

And who knows what else is being discussed.

He will see less top matchups which should help him. Eichel will shelter him.

MAKE THE TRADE, ADAMS!
- Powerslave

I posted last page, they are talking with the Flames for Monahan and the 8th is involved also.

If that's the deal, you're going to have to come to terms with it.

And who knows what else is being discussed.
- Powerslave

I’m tired of losing trades.

Monahan helps tomorrow, however the 8th overall pick most likely gives you a similar quality player with much more team control

In a few years from now we are sitting here crying about Monahan and how he’s a passenger and useless defensively when Rossi/Holtz/Lundell/Perfetti are lighting it up in Calgary.

I posted last page, they are talking with the Flames for Monahan and the 8th is involved also.
- SABRES 89

Mitts + 8th

Or

Risto + the 8th

I don’t mind the Risto one

I'm on board.

Bring him in!
- Powerslave

He had a disappointing season this year, but he averages over 60pts a year. Then go out and get Jesper Fast and put him at RW.

I’m tired of losing trades.

Monahan helps tomorrow, however the 8th overall pick most likely gives you a similar quality player with much more team control

In a few years from now we are sitting here crying about Monahan and how he’s a passenger and useless defensively when Rossi/Holtz/Lundell/Perfetti are lighting it up in Calgary.
- Pegullaville

This

He had a disappointing season this year, but he averages over 60pts a year. Then go out and get Jesper Fast and put him at RW.
- Buff36

You are getting moar good players to play with other good players.

Seems risky.

If you like him, he's an 80 point player.

If you don't like him, he's a 50 point player.

If you're being factual, he's a 60-70 point player.

See how fun this is.
- TheSabresTaco

Apparently his own fan base agrees


DFF said: ↑
Johnny is not a superstar like mcdavid or McKinnon. He is the next tier. But he carried 2 mediocre 40 pt guys to point per game career years. Good luck getting equal value for him. What they really need is top line players to play and share the load with him.... Monahan and Lindholm got outplayed by a plug like Reider... what a joke.
and it's not the first time.

Monahan was on pace for 50 without Gaudreau,


Next