So what you're saying is that when ASKAROV is dominating the league at the top of goalie stat categories, that somehow isn't worth taking him at 4 compared to a defender who is a top 4 on the Wings or a forward who is top 9?
And that somehow if Askarov doesn't end up being an elite or even top tier goalie that's worse than getting a defender who isn't in the top 4 or a forward who doesn't make the top 9?
Maybe if great goalies grew on trees, but they don't and this kid dominates everywhere he plays and is currently 3 games deep in the KHL at 18 with a .974 Sv% and 0.74 GAA.
Honestly I'd be surprised if he would even be available at the Wings on 4. This would be the icing on the rebuild. No matter what you need elite goaltending and where else are the wings going to get it? Meanwhile it is far easier to get top 6 forwards and top 4 D. Y'all are silly
- VonDouche
In the last 10 seasons, 16 different goalies have finished top-3 in Vezina voting at least once. Here's who they are, and how their teams acquired them prior to their Vezina finalist season(s):
Connor Hellebucyk: Drafted 130th overall
Andrei Vasilevskiy: Drafted 19th overall
Tuukka Rask: Acquired by trade
Ben Bishop: Acquired by trade (heโs been traded three times in his career and his Vezina nominations have all come with his third and fourth teams)
Robin Lehner: Signed as a free agent
Pekka Rinne: Drafted 258th overall
Sergei Bobrovsky: Acquired by trade
Braden Holtby: Drafted 93rd overall
Carey Price: Drafted 5th overall
Jonathan Quick: Drafted 72nd overall
Devan Dubnyk: Signed as a free agent and traded midseason
Semyon Varlamov: Acquired by trade
Henrik Lundqvist: Drafted 205th overall
Antti Niemi: Signed as free agent
Tim Thomas: Signed as a free agent
Roberto Luongo: Acquired by trade
To summarize, only 7 out of 16 (less than half) were playing with their original NHL organizations when they earned their first Vezina nomination, and only 2 out of 16 (Vasilevsky and Price), who combined for 5 out of the 30 total nominations in the 10-year period, were
both drafted in the first round
and still playing for their original teams.
EDIT: So that you can see it a little bit more cleanly, here are those "how were they acquired" bits again in a more organized, easy-to-read way. Again, this includes every goaltender with at least one top-3 Vezina finish in the last decade:
5th overall
19th overall
72nd overall
93rd overall
130th overall
205th overall
258th overall
Traded
Traded
Traded
Traded
Traded
Traded
UFA
UFA
UFA