You can think it's hilarious, but the math says he was pedestrian at best after 18-19. You don't need to accept it, but it's a fact.

The goalies you listed have been just as good as Gibson since 18-19.
- TheSabresTaco

You listed them and they both have played on good teams since 18-19

I mean Craig played better with a .915 last year if you wanna base it strictly off save % and no added context

then this year.... not so good

Hasek woulda looked pedestrian on those teams

- DirtyDan

ok dan

You listed them and they both have played on good teams since 18-19

- DirtyDan

Anton Forsberg?

I mean Craig played better with a .915 last year if you wanna base it strictly off save % and no added context

then this year.... not so good
- DirtyDan

I've done this zero times.

Anton Forsberg?
- TheSabresTaco

Ottawa played sound D... there game was not run and gun like Anaheim.

Man I thought you were better than this

I've done this zero times.
- TheSabresTaco

You clearly did.... "Individual performance" something something "nothing to do with better team"

Ottawa played sound D... there game was not run and gun like Anaheim.

Man I thought you were better than this
- DirtyDan

So we've moved from, they're not a good team to 'oh well ottawa plays a sound d'

yeah I think we're done here.

So we've moved from, they're not a good team to 'oh well ottawa plays a sound d'

yeah I think we're done here.
- TheSabresTaco

I stated before the type of game Anaheim played


Follow along big guy

Matt Murray was a better goalie than John Gibson this year.
- TheSabresTaco

Despite my fantasy hockey rankings, john gibson has been compared to vaslevsky.

*The comparer was probably inebriated though

Despite my fantasy hockey rankings, john gibson has been compared vaslevsky.

*The comparer was probably inebriated though
- Boss34

holy christ.

Gibson's 18-19 was better than Vasy's 21-22. Not by much.

Shesterkin blew them both out of the water.

holy christ.

Gibson's 18-19 was better than Vasy's 21-22. Not by much.

Shesterkin blew them both out of the water.
- TheSabresTaco

So to be clear you'd take any of your listed over Gibson?

You can think it's hilarious, but the math says he was pedestrian at best after 18-19. You don't need to accept it, but it's a fact.

The goalies you listed have been just as good as Gibson since 18-19.
- TheSabresTaco

Riddle me this tacoman

Why would the biggest brain on here (unlceionlightning) think gibson was as good as vaslevsky?

Doesnt make sense

holy christ.

Gibson's 18-19 was better than Vasy's 21-22. Not by much.

Shesterkin blew them both out of the water.
- TheSabresTaco

That wasnt the comparison.


Player vs player

Drunk vs sober posters.

Vaslevsky has since proven big brain small red hat wrong.

So to be clear you'd take any of your listed over Gibson?
- DirtyDan

I didn't say that either, and to answer you directly, no. I don't want any of them.

Riddle me this tacoman

Why would the biggest brain on here (unlceionlightning) think gibson was as good as vaslevsky?

Doesnt make sense
- Boss34

I didn't see that comment, but it's aged 3 years after the Best By date.

That wasnt the comparison.


Player vs player

Drunk vs sober posters.

Vaslevsky has since proven big brain small red hat wrong.
- Boss34

To be fair to Gibson he actually had an excellent start to this season. It's just that he was so bad afterwards that it tanked his overall impact to his team into the negatives.

How about this!! Just get a decent F@cking Goalie.

I'd take a flier on Vanacek actually. Don't think he would cost too much.

I'd take a flier on Vanacek actually. Don't think he would cost too much.
- TheSabresTaco

He's predicted to get a 4 year deal at $5M per.

Still interested?

I didn't say that either, and to answer you directly, no. I don't want any of them.
- TheSabresTaco

Whos your pick then?

How about this!! Just get a decent F@cking Goalie.
- Buff36

I actually had a dream we landed Gibson for like a prospect a second and a 3rd

I remember thinking in dreamland "not even a first in there! that's a steal"

To be fair to Gibson he actually had an excellent start to this season. It's just that he was so bad afterwards that it tanked his overall impact to his team into the negatives.
- TheSabresTaco

Talbot of MAF seem like the targets IMO.

1 of those guys will probably be moved this summer.

He's predicted to get a 4 year deal at $5M per.

Still interested?
- kingcong39

That's surprising with 79gms played so far.

That's surprising with 79gms played so far.
- Buff36

He only has one year left before becoming a UFA.

That is a factor.