To be fair the Beatles are far better than either. I have no doubts they could enter any era musically as young adults and kick ass.
- golfingsince

Oh for sure. The Beatles are incredibly intelligent musicians and writers. They could do anything they wanted.
Green Day were simply angry teenagers for their first 15 years. Angry, angsty teenagers in an era where that energy was at its peak. They were both a symptom of and a cure for 90s societal rebellion. That era has faded quite a bit. I dont think they'd hold up if they had to start over as 19 years olds in 2023.
That being said, i guess angsty teens are a tale as old as time. Maybe theyd be ok? Hard to know for sure.

If we can't agree on anything else from here on out, that's okay because we'll always have Stranger Things.
A goddamn cinematic masterpiece.
- UsernameUnknown

Dude. Season 5 might kill me. If my Boy Steve dies, I'm gonna be pissed.

Watching the movie Yesterday really hammered home how franking good they were.

Their franking drummer wrote hits.
- Atomic Wedgie

To me The Beatles enter any discussion of the greatest band of all time and it's been decades since I've really enjoyed their music.

Tkachuk shot too early

Both teams playing some loose hockey in this OT so far.

Greg Millen is surprisingly annoying.
- joel878

try listening to Jack Edwards... Millen is a genius by comparison

Not what I had in mind but interested to see how it plays out 🤔
- joel878

They were talking overrated bands. Probably why Queen hasn't entered the conversation either?

Dude. Season 5 might kill me. If my Boy Steve dies, I'm gonna be pissed.
- GreatGigInTheSky

Steve my die, man. I don't know. Gotta protect the kids.

And its an easy way to fix that really annoying love triangle they got going on. The only flaw in season 4 was jamming that in there. I dont like it. The rest was perfect.

To me The Beatles enter any discussion of the greatest band of all time and it's been decades since I've really enjoyed their music.

Tkachuk shot too early
- golfingsince

I don’t really know who would compete with them.

Rolling Stones.

Some would say U2

Looking for suggestions here - I’m not a music guy.

They were talking overrated bands. Probably why Queen hasn't entered the conversation either?
- golfingsince

Queen was fantastic. Another example of a band in which any damn member could do or write something spectacular at any given moment.

try listening to Jack Edwards... Millen is a genius by comparison

- BorjeFan4Ever

Yeah, I'd never listen to that moron Edwards. Millen has been trying to write the panthers off since halfway through the third. It's annoying how hard he's going out of his way to pump Boston's tires. He's Jack Edwards without the Tucker Carlson like hot takes and annoying pitch to his voice when he has em.

Queen was fantastic. Another example of a band in which any damn member could do or write something spectacular at any given moment.
- UsernameUnknown

Same with the Police.

They were talking overrated bands. Probably why Queen hasn't entered the conversation either?
- golfingsince

Yeah I definitely missed that part. My bad. 🤦

Queen was fantastic. Another example of a band in which any damn member could do or write something spectacular at any given moment.
- UsernameUnknown

The Eagles 👀

Same with the Police.
- Atomic Wedgie

I dont know their deeper dives but their radio hits drive me nuts. They're so repetitive. Their song structures go:
Verse- 4 bars
Chrorus- 2 bars (repeat ×64)
Outro.

Hard to believe Led Zeppelin has yet to enter this conversation.
- joel878

Radiohead for the win. Every time.

I don’t really know who would compete with them.

Rolling Stones.

Some would say U2

Looking for suggestions here - I’m not a music guy.
- Atomic Wedgie

U2 is not in that discussion.

Boston music guy very a propos with territorial pissings and fight fire with fire

Steve my die, man. I don't know. Gotta protect the kids.

And its an easy way to fix that really annoying love triangle they got going on. The only flaw in season 4 was jamming that in there. I dont like it. The rest was perfect.
- UsernameUnknown

It's true that he's the best mom on the show.

That's how I'm thinking it's gonna happen. Sacrifice himself to save Nancy. And I agree, I hate the triangle.

U2 is not in that discussion.
- Zezel

It's a beautiful day

If we can't agree on anything else from here on out, that's okay because we'll always have Stranger Things.
A goddamn cinematic masterpiece.
- UsernameUnknown

It's a middling memberberry tv show

The Eagles 👀
- joel878

I like the Eagles but I think those other bands are a couple of tiers ahead. We all have our own tastes however.

The Eagles 👀
- joel878

Another great one for me.

Some of my musical hot takes today haven't been so hot so I'm going to try again.

Guns and Roses is absolutely a top 15 band of all time. Arguably top 10.

Also if we want to go back to the overrated discussion- AC/DC is only okay.

Yes!!!!!!!

Bring on the cats

lol

Good luck next round

Florida!