Uhhh, NOPE! 🤣😅😂

A mock Carter Hart trade that could make sense to me:
To Philly:
Jordan Greenway
A 1st round pick (13th overall)
Devin Levi

To Buffalo:
Carter Hart
Mid round pick

https://twitter.com/mgaff...Bii1FHkniZ0PmJB-k6iQ&s=19

Uhhh, NOPE! 🤣😅😂

A mock Carter Hart trade that could make sense to me:
To Philly:
Jordan Greenway
A 1st round pick (13th overall)
Devin Levi

To Buffalo:
Carter Hart
Mid round pick

https://twitter.com/mgaff...Bii1FHkniZ0PmJB-k6iQ&s=19
- kingcong39

Tweet was deleted.

Uhhh, NOPE! 🤣😅😂

A mock Carter Hart trade that could make sense to me:
To Philly:
Jordan Greenway
A 1st round pick (13th overall)
Devin Levi

To Buffalo:
Carter Hart
Mid round pick

https://twitter.com/mgaff...Bii1FHkniZ0PmJB-k6iQ&s=19
- kingcong39

😆

sounds like its the oilers for hart

https://twitter.com/Jamey...tatus/1666157695022383104

Tweet was deleted.
- ImThatGuy

As it should be. Greenway is definitely negative value but jfc

Draft status? What do you mean?
- kingcong39

He was a 2nd rounder and the first goalie selected in that draft

Uhhh, NOPE! 🤣😅😂

A mock Carter Hart trade that could make sense to me:
To Philly:
Jordan Greenway
A 1st round pick (13th overall)
Devin Levi

To Buffalo:
Carter Hart
Mid round pick

https://twitter.com/mgaff...Bii1FHkniZ0PmJB-k6iQ&s=19
- kingcong39

I just threw up in my mouth, a lot

Uhhh, NOPE! 🤣😅😂

A mock Carter Hart trade that could make sense to me:
To Philly:
Jordan Greenway
A 1st round pick (13th overall)
Devin Levi

To Buffalo:
Carter Hart
Mid round pick

https://twitter.com/mgaff...Bii1FHkniZ0PmJB-k6iQ&s=19
- kingcong39

Go big, I guess

Go big, I guess
- joshs

That package might make sense for an elite keeper like Helleybuck. That's a massive overpay for a guy who has been up and down in this league.

That package might make sense for an elite keeper like Helleybuck. That's a massive overpay for a guy who has been up and down in this league.
- Slump Buster

I'd do that for helley yesterday. Hart? 😆

I'd do that for helley yesterday. Hart? 😆
- TheHank

I wouldn't make that trade for a goalie as the position doesn't warrant it. As for Hart, would it be a surprise if Levi ended up having the better career?

He was a 2nd rounder and the first goalie selected in that draft
- sbroads24

And might not be the best Goalie in the draft.

I wouldn't make that trade for a goalie as the position doesn't warrant it. As for Hart, would it be a surprise if Levi ended up having the better career?
- Slump Buster

No but it wouldn't surprise me if Hart had the better career either. That's the point. The position is entirely too volatile to assume the rookie you have now is the guy you win with.

How about...

Hart - 13th pick
Helly - UPL, '24 1st
Levi

Triple Entente

No but it wouldn't surprise me if Hart had the better career either. That's the point. The position is entirely too volatile to assume the rookie you have now is the guy you win with.
- Michael Ghofrani

Sure, Hart might end up having the better career, and that's my point. He is another lottery ticket. He has a higher draft position and flashes of being very good... that isn't enough for me to throw a massive package to get. I think the better teams have multiple lottery tickets and the best you can do is hope one of them takes off (particularly in the playoffs).

I wouldn't make that trade for a goalie as the position doesn't warrant it. As for Hart, would it be a surprise if Levi ended up having the better career?
- Slump Buster

You're giving up 2 total unknowns and a 4th liner for arguably the best goalie (definitely top 3) in the world. At face value its highway robbery.
Would it be a surprise if Levi has a better career that Hart? Not at all.

No but it wouldn't surprise me if Hart had the better career either. That's the point. The position is entirely too volatile to assume the rookie you have now is the guy you win with.
- Michael Ghofrani

Yep.
Would it be a surprise if you win with helley? Don't answer, it's rhetorical.

You're giving up 2 total unknowns and a 4th liner for arguably the best goalie (definitely top 3) in the world. At face value its highway robbery.
Would it be a surprise if Levi has a better career that Hart? Not at all.
- TheHank

Right - it would be a fair package for Helleybuck, but I still wouldn't make the trade given his age and contract status.

No but it wouldn't surprise me if Hart had the better career either. That's the point. The position is entirely too volatile to assume the rookie you have now is the guy you win with.
- Michael Ghofrani

Exactly why you shouldn’t pay big assets for it.

Sure, Hart might end up having the better career, and that's my point. He is another lottery ticket. He has a higher draft position and flashes of being very good... that isn't enough for me to throw a massive package to get. I think the better teams have multiple lottery tickets and the best you can do is hope one of them takes off (particularly in the playoffs).
- Slump Buster

Goalies are what they are. Draft position means absolutely nothing.

Goalies are what they are. Draft position means absolutely nothing.
- TheHank

I agree completely, but not everyone does. I don't think that trade proposal is made if Levi and Hart swapped draft positions. People hang on to that stuff.

Exactly why you shouldn’t pay big assets for it.
- Swedish_Jesus

Flip it around at the same time. Its exactly why you shouldn't count on an unknown quantity.

I agree completely, but not everyone does. I don't think that trade proposal is made if Levi and Hart swapped draft positions. People hang on to that stuff.
- Slump Buster

Yes they do. Any other position I think it makes sense just not for goaltenders.

Flip it around at the same time. Its exactly why you shouldn't count on an unknown quantity.
- TheHank

I think unless you get one of the top 3 goalies, you kind of have to count on an unknown quantity. It seems like most of the league had their goaltending situations go sideways at some point, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing as the unexpected goalie ended up being *good enough*.

Exactly why you shouldn’t pay big assets for it.
- Swedish_Jesus

Also why you shouldn’t yet count on Levi being an all star…..