n. “We definitely had conversations with Philadelphia, we had very respectable conversations with Philadelphia about it, we’ve chosen just to take the high road and leave all that information private.”
- furio16
Pierre Le Brun in The Athletic
"The world wants to know!
OK, maybe just the hockey world.
But why exactly did Cutter Gauthier decide he didn’t want to be a Philadelphia Flyer, forcing a trade?
I asked Gauthier’s rep, veteran NHL agent Kurt Overhardt, on Tuesday.
“It’s a private issue between the player and his family,” Overhardt said over the phone from Stockholm. “We definitely had conversations with Philadelphia. We had very respectable conversations with Philadelphia about it. We’ve chosen just to take the high road and leave all that information private.
“The good news is, obviously Cutter has a new opportunity with Anaheim and the Flyers were able to get really good assets for the player. So everyone just needs to move forward.”
Some of the speculation that immediately followed the trade was that the root issue was Flyers head coach John Tortorella — that perhaps Overhardt didn’t want his client to play for him.
Overhardt vehemently denied that Tortorella had any bearing whatsoever on this decision, again reiterating that it was a private matter.
Elliotte Friedman of Sportsnet said Tuesday it could have to do with the Flyers not wanting to sign him after his 2022-23 college season, citing a team bonus overage salary cap issue.
right after Gauthier’s world juniors performance was probably as perfect timing as it got.
Could that have been interpreted by the player as a lack of faith from the organization? Or led to the relationship to sour? Remember that signing to go pro late in the season burns the first year of an NHL entry-level contract, which is enticing for many college players.
I asked Overhardt about that, and again he declined to comment.
The Flyers didn’t have more info to offer, saying Tuesday they’re still unsure why Gauthier wouldn’t sign or speak with them.
“I really don’t know,” general manager Danny Briere told The Athletic. “I kept asking Kurt over and over two questions: Why can’t we meet with them so we can at least just present our case and tell him what we’re trying to do and how we are building this team and saw Cutter being a core part of it? And the other question is:
OK, if you don’t want to play in Philadelphia, can we know the reason? We couldn’t get an answer on either one.”
Huge props to Briere for not only turning lemons into lemonade but perhaps Champagne in getting 21-year-old blueliner Jamie Drysdale and a second-round pick out of it. The longer this went, the less leverage Philadelphia likely had as teams found out that Gauthier wasn’t going to sign with the Flyers.
There were a few teams in the mix, but the Ducks rose to the forefront.
“We looked at teams that had good young defensemen in the range of below 23 years old,” Briere said. “We had a few targets, but it’s not very often you get a chance to get a guy like Drysdale, a 21-year-old defenseman with the high-end hockey skills that he has. So Anaheim quickly became one of the targets for us.”
Gauthier wouldn’t have become an unrestricted free agent until the summer of 2026 (after four college years), so the Flyers could have waited longer, but getting it done right after Gauthier’s world juniors performance was probably as perfect timing as it got.
“We figured with what happened at the world juniors, and how he played and the stats that he put out, we thought this might be the best opportunity to get the most out of him if he doesn’t want to play in Philadelphia,” Briere said. “We could have kept trying to get in touch with him, but if they don’t want to meet up with us and listen to our side and what we’re trying to build here, at some point you’ve got to move on and get the most out of the situation. And that’s the reason we felt this was a good time to do it.”
Still, the whole thing was frustrating, to be sure.
Flyers, prevented from talking to Cutter Gauthier, still don’t know what went wrong
“It was a disappointing process,” Briere said. “We still think it was the right pick at that time looking back. It was the right pick to make. That’s why we got the return that we got for that pick. We can sit here and feel sorry for ourselves, but nothing’s going to change.
“We’re excited with what we got. Jamie’s now our guy. And that’s super exciting. That’s the way we see it at this point. I’m glad it’s over and we can move on and make the most of it.”
Ducks GM Pat Verbeek, meanwhile, jumped all over the opportunity once he got wind of Gauthier’s availability. The fact is that Verbeek had actually tried to get Gauthier back at the 2022 draft, looking to deal for another high pick so he could select Gauthier, who went fifth to the Flyers.
We’ll look back at this trade in 10 years and debate who won it. It’s pretty rare for two blue chips to get dealt for each other this early in their respective careers.