P/GP he was 48th.
TOI/GP he's 57th, but let's dig a little deeper:
EVTOI/GP he's 38th.
PPTOI/GP he's 38th.
SHTOI/GP he's 235th.
Scoring/60, 5v5 (adding the filter of GP>40) he's 60th.
- Atomic Wedgie
To try and classify a 2nd Centre I took all of the players in the league and sorted them by faceoffs and took the top 200 guys in faceoffs and then sorted them by ice time and counted which centres on which team had the most time on ice and took the 2nd most among those remaining centres.
This left me with a list of around 30 centres - I discounted some guys who were traded mid-year (like Hertl or Mittelstadt - largely because with a change in environment, roles can change, distribution can change and so on - and I'm not doing a deep dive, just a cursory look at some data) - and basically among 2nd line centres, Tavares is 6th in points:
Leon Draisaitl makes $8.5m until 2024-25 and had 106 points
J.T. Miller makes $8m until 2029-30 and had 103 points
Mika Zibanejad makes $8.5m until 2029-30 and had 72 points
Brock Nelson makes $6m until 2024-25 and had 69 points
Evgeni Malkin makes $6.1m until 2025-26 and had 67 points
John Tavares makes $11m until 2024-25 and had 65 points
Matt Duchene makes $3m until 2024-25 and had 65 points
Charlie Coyle makes $5.25m until 2025-26 and had 60 points
Sean Monahan makes $5.5m until 2028-29 and had 59 points
Casey Mittelstadt makes $5.75m until 2026-27 and had 57 points
Chandler Stephenson makes $6.25m until 2030-31 and had 51 points
J.T. Compher makes $5.1m until 2027-28 and had 48 points
Phillip Danault makes $5.5m until 2026-27 and had 47 points
Brayden Schenn makes $6.5m until 2027-28 and had 46 points
Anthony Cirelli makes $6.25m until 2030-31 and had 45 points
Alexander Kerfoot makes $3.5m until 2024-25 and had 45 points
Mason McTavish makes $0.89m until 2024-25 and had 42 points
Sam Bennett makes $4.43m until 2024-25 and had 41 points
Morgan Frost makes $2.1m until 2024-25 and had 41 points
Marco Rossi makes $0.86m until 2024-25 and had 40 points
Ross Colton makes $4m until 2026-27 and had 40 points
Mikael Backlund makes $4.5m until 2025-26 and had 39 points
Matthew Beniers makes $0.9m but is an expired RFA and had 37 points
Erik Haula makes $3.15m until 2025-26 and had 35 points
Colton Sissons makes $2.86m until 2025-26 and had 35 points
Adam Lowry makes $3.25m until 2025-26 and had 35 points
Cole Sillinger makes $0.93m until 2023-24 and had 32 points
Jordan Staal makes $2.9m until 2026-27 and had 30 points
Evgeny Kuznetsov makes $7.8m until 2024-25 and had 24 points
Nico Sturm makes $2m until 2024-25 and had 13 points
The problem isn't his production. The problem is that - even if you discount the RFAs in the list - the average salary here is $5.3m and Tavares makes $2.5m more than anyone else on the list.
You could make a case that on a new deal JT maybe could command $5m, but given that he is going to be moving to the wing as he ages and is no longer a centre, that value should probably go down further.