Anyone who pots 30-35 goals in this league is considered a goal scorer. Once can be a fluke, but multiples are the sign of a goal scorer. I think most would agree here.
Getting around 50 goals put you into "sniper" territory. Again, I think most would agree here.
Scoring 69 goals is (frank)ing legend. That's double the production of a good goal scorer in a single season.
Therefore, with Ovi about to beat Gretzky's record and taking into account Mustache's legendary scoring, it is safe to say that if Matthews stays healthy, he will break Ovi's record which was Gretzky's.
Therefore, Matthews is better than Gretzky, Case closed.
- GalacticStone
I like your argument, but . . . .we see a lot of eggheads go on and on about ERA adjusted scoring and if they use that it already suggests Ovechkin is the greatest goal scorer of all team - but a part of that is because they diminish the contributions of Wayne Gretzky or Mario Lemieux to the game itself. They look at league average scoring and use higher point seasons to reduce the overall average - but what was the effect of having Gretzky or Lemieux in a game? How many players were getting more points than just the individual? If you look at goals / season - there is a distinct spike only when Gretzky and Lemieux are in their prime. That was their impact to and on the game. They made the entire league's average goals/game noticeably rise.
I always liked the comparison of a player in-a-season to peers who were not on their team. How much better were you than everyone else in that year?
This is the top-20 for
points:
Wayne Gretzky in 1986-87 was 41.53% ahead of the next closest.
Wayne Gretzky in 1983-84 was 40.49% ahead of the next closest.
Phil Esposito in 1973-74 was 40% ahead of the next closest.
Wayne Gretzky in 1984-85 was 37.5% ahead of the next closest.
Phil Esposito in 1970-71 was 36.84% ahead of the next closest.
Wayne Gretzky in 1982-83 was 36.73% ahead of the next closest.
Gordie Howe in 1952-53 was 35.79% ahead of the next closest.
Wayne Gretzky in 1985-86 was 34.42% ahead of the next closest.
Connor McDavid in 2020-21 was 34.29% ahead of the next closest.
Wayne Gretzky in 1981-82 was 30.66% ahead of the next closest.
Bobby Orr in 1969-70 was 28.33% ahead of the next closest.
Stan Mikita in 1966-67 was 27.84% ahead of the next closest.
Connor McDavid in 2022-23 was 26.61% ahead of the next closest.
Mario Lemieux in 1995-96 was 25.47% ahead of the next closest.
Gordie Howe in 1951-52 was 24.42% ahead of the next closest.
Gordie Howe in 1950-51 was 23.26% ahead of the next closest.
Phil Esposito in 1972-73 was 20% ahead of the next closest.
Wayne Gretzky in 1990-91 was 19.63% ahead of the next closest.
Bobby Hull in 1965-66 was 19.59% ahead of the next closest.
Phil Esposito in 1971-72 was 18.05% ahead of the next closest.
And this is the top-20 for
goals:
In 1965-66 Bobby Hull led by 40.74%
In 1990-91 Brett Hull led by 40.7%
In 1983-84 Wayne Gretzky led by 35.63%
In 1952-53 Gordie Howe led by 34.69%
In 1951-52 Gordie Howe led by 34.04%
In 1961-62 Bobby Hull led by 34%
In 1970-71 Phil Esposito led by 32.89%
In 1966-67 Bobby Hull led by 32.69%
In 1981-82 Wayne Gretzky led by 30.43%
In 1956-57 Gordie Howe led by 25%
In 1971-72 Phil Esposito led by 24.24%
In 1999-00 Pavel Bure led by 24.14%
In 1973-74 Phil Esposito led by 23.53%
In 1991-92 Brett Hull led by 22.86%
In 2001-02 Jarome Iginla led by 21.15%
In 1987-88 Mario Lemieux led by 20%
In 2007-08 Alex Ovechkin led by 20%
In 2020-21 Auston Matthews led by 19.51%
In 1955-56 Jean Beliveau led by 19.15%
In 2014-15 Alex Ovechkin led by 18.87%
Ovechkin doesn't really dominate the goals list - but he is where he is because he is consistently one of the top producers year after year and because it's incredibly infrequent that he's injured.