Pulling the plug on and injured JVR will be Patrick Sharp all over again
- Scottie Upshall

Not really. If they get Schenn, they're getting a proven NHLer, not a guy who is unproven like Matt Ellison. Also all reputable reporters say that if the deal is made, it will be more than Schenn coming back.

Apples and oranges to Sharp.

Carle will not sign for 4M. He can do far better in Free Agency.
- MJL

Then let someone overpay
I would throw up if they gave him 5mill

Pulling the plug on and injured JVR will be Patrick Sharp all over again
- Scottie Upshall

It's not like we would be trading him for an ahl'er

Pulling the plug on and injured JVR will be Patrick Sharp all over again
- Scottie Upshall

Wait I'm confused. You've suggested trading JvR how many times and now you're saying it wouldn't be a good idea. What am I missing?

Not really. If they get Schenn, they're getting a proven NHLer, not a guy who is unproven like Matt Ellison. Also all reputable reporters say that if the deal is made, it will be more than Schenn coming back.

Apples and oranges to Sharp.
- Jsaquella

I agree, but JVR will be a better player in the longer run.
They give Schenn and Colborne and I make the deal

Then let someone overpay
I would throw up if they gave him 5mill
- Scottie Upshall

Why? He's worth it.

Wait I'm confused. You've suggested trading JvR how many times and now you're saying it wouldn't be a good idea. What am I missing?
- LJF

I wouldn't trade JVR for Schenn and Kadri

How bout jvr mab for schenn and kulinem. Or however u spell his name

Why? He's worth it.
- MJL

Rather pay a better defender like Suter a little more

I agree, but JVR will be a better player in the longer run.
They give Schenn and Colborne and I make the deal
- Scottie Upshall

He could be, but let's see what the deal is, or if it even happens.

The Flyers are not shopping JvR, nor has he asked to be traded. Toronto approached the Flyers, so the Flyers should be able to set the price they want, and not make a move if it's not met.

There's a lot of different ways that they could make a deal with the Leafs that would be fair for both teams.

Rather pay a better defender like Suter a little more
- Scottie Upshall

So would I. But that doesn't mean I would throw up to sign a good player what he's worth.

I wouldn't trade JVR for Schenn and Kadri
- Scottie Upshall

Kadri's a better prospect than Colborne.

So would I. But that doesn't mean I would throw up to sign a good player what he's worth.
- MJL

Carle isn't worth 5mill

Kadri's a better prospect than Colborne.
- Jsaquella

Never liked him

Carle isn't worth 5mill
- Scottie Upshall

The stats and comparable players with his stats say otherwise.

I'd like to see Rinaldo get back in the line up. I know most probably won't agree, but sit Harry Z and bring Rinaldo back in.

The stats and comparable players with his stats say otherwise.
- MBFlyerfan

I couldn't pay him more then Mez

I'd like to see Rinaldo get back in the line up. I know most probably won't agree, but sit Harry Z and bring Rinaldo back in.
- LJF

I'd like to see Jagr sit until he's 100%

I'd like to see Rinaldo get back in the line up. I know most probably won't agree, but sit Harry Z and bring Rinaldo back in.
- LJF

I think both of them deserve ice time. Unfortunately one has to sit. I think we see Rinaldo sooner than later.

Carle isn't worth 5mill
- Scottie Upshall

Why isn't he?

I think both of them deserve ice time. Unfortunately one has to sit. I think we see Rinaldo sooner than later.
- MBFlyerfan

I agree and that's a great problem to have.

I'd like to see Rinaldo get back in the line up. I know most probably won't agree, but sit Harry Z and bring Rinaldo back in.
- LJF

I like both players, and both deserve to play.

Why isn't he?
- MJL

Because he's not a big physical player, just a skilled, very solid one.

Because he's not a big physical player, just a skilled, very solid one.
- Jsaquella

Just to be sure, is that sarcasm?

please fill in the blanks

weber-$ per year
suter-$ per year
carle-$ per year

id love to see what everyone thinks