Sorry. It was that, or...
- hscesq

at least it wasn't the latter

unlike most Leaf fans I am sensible I don't overvalue our players.... Montreal does with every one of theirs.

Schenn isn't worth JVR + a 1st like morons are reporting.. nor do I think Kadri + schenn and a 1st could get us Getzlaf/Nash like most the idiot fans do, for Bobby Ryan maybe.. but not those two.

The only people on our team I would consider right now untouchables are Phaneuf, Kessel, Lupol, and Gardiner(who's not having a good yr but I see potential) everyone else would be an improvement in a trade I am sure.. so do not tell me I overvalue my teams players.
- beleaf4ever

This comment renders all else that you post, pretty much irrelevant. Making a sweeping generalization like that, really diminishes credibility.

Finally, Montreal gets that big, hardnosed center upfront.

wait, Derek Roy?!


- clarkysduster

LOL please do it Gauthier. Set the Scabs back another couple years
- skelly96

LIKE

at least it wasn't the latter
- bonzo11

I'm here to help.

Why would Montreal do this?

I would rather have Eller than Roy.
I would rather have Subban than Myers.

::EDIT::
Actually if I was montreal I would rather have Myers. They need all the size they can get.

But if I hear correctly from Buffalo fans Roy is a poison, and I wouldn't want him on my team if that's true.
- Scruffton

You're kidding right? We'd never do that. Myers >>>>Subban

I am sure I speak for most of the Sabres fans when I say no thanks .

Montreal does not have one player on their roster I would want in a Sabres uniform.

Not a one !

For picks ? Now that I will do just to purge Roys salary for free agency during the summer .

I do not want anyone from that roster .
- TerryPegs

While I agree that Montreal's roster very low on players I would want, anything to get Roy out of a Sabre's uniform sounds good to me. Guy is a cancer to team chemistry.

Why does Buffalo need to get anybody back? Dump him as addition by subtraction.

Replace Roy with Szczechura from Rochester.
- GoinFiveHole

cause he has value and you dont just give away assets.

You're kidding right? We'd never do that. Myers >>>>Subban
- Homer

Actually, not really. At least not yet. Maybe some day.

How can you laugh when the stats show it... Schenn 24 giveaways / 23 takeaways almost a 1:1 ratio... Suban 47 giveaways to 13 takeaways... guy is a liability on the ice.

For an offensive defenseman he has put up 5 more points than our Stay at home D man? averaging 7+ minutes more a game.


You guys overvalue Subban because if Schenn is supposed to be a stay at home D man and is putting up similar numbers with less ice time.. makes me want to see what Schenn will develop into.
- beleaf4ever

for who?
- gsmith004

My guess...

Ryder, Halak and a 2nd

Actually, not really. At least not yet. Maybe some day.
- hscesq

I think we should all fight about it. . .

Actually, not really. At least not yet. Maybe some day.
- hscesq

fair argument I guess

yeah, Gautheir is trying to keep his job, and he's doing a terrible JOB at it.
- pugnacious.serf

Don't know, the Cammalleri trade was a good one from a rebuild stand point, if he can pull some other trades like that out of his butt...

I just hope he and Molson are intelligent enough to understand playoff is an utopia at this point

- clarkysduster

Schenn isn't playing the minutes Subban is. They are asking him to do WAY too much, and he is putting even more on himself. He's having an awful season, to be sure.

Actually, not really. At least not yet. Maybe some day.
- hscesq

We'll gladly take Cole for Roy. I know Cole was close to signing here in the off season, real close.

I think we should all fight about it. . .
- ImThatGuy

You mean one big fight? Or square off?

Actually, not really. At least not yet. Maybe some day.
- hscesq

Like I said Earlier, I take Myers based on his Chara-like potential. Size and foot-speed in Myers' case, are a rare combination that you do not let go. But come on... both Subban and Myers are on their respective GM's "Untouchable" list.

We'll gladly take Cole for Roy. I know Cole was close to signing here in the off season, real close.
- Homer

That guy has been everything we expected and more. Love that guy. Wish we had 12 of him.

Schenn isn't playing the minutes Subban is. They are asking him to do WAY too much, and he is putting even more on himself. He's having an awful season, to be sure.
- hscesq

you admitt he is having an awful season yet wont admitt Myers is better?

That guy has been everything we expected and more. Love that guy. Wish we had 12 of him.
- hscesq

I know him personally.....thought you over paid for him, guess not

Like I said Earlier, I take Myers based on his Chara-like potential. Size and foot-speed in Myers' case, are a rare combination that you do not let go. But come on... both Subban and Myers are on their respective GM's "Untouchable" list.
- Cimo

To each his own. Myers isn't nearly as mean as Chara though, and you can't teach mean. But you are probably right about being untouchables.

Roy + 3rd
for
Kostitsyn + Desharnais

- ImThatGuy

No fcking way I want Kostitsyn anywhere near this dressing room or to ever have the privilege of werain a Sabres sweater .

No thank you , once again to anyone on the Montreal roster . I will gladly take picks for Roy but not any waste on that roster .

That roster is far worse than Buffalos .

you admitt he is having an awful season yet wont admitt Myers is better?
- Homer

That's correct. Why can't both be true?

good, you?
- bonzo11

Pretty well for a Friday. Going to a hold'em tournament this wknd.