If I do that for you what will you do for me?
- prock

Pick one of each pair:

Seguin or Skinner
Backes or Kesler
Ladd or Nash
Duchene or Eberle
M.Richards or B.Schenn
Kessel or Neal
Subban or Myers
Toews or Stamkos
Clarkson or Lucic
Doughty or Petriangelo

Pick one of each pair:

Seguin or Skinner
Backes or Kesler
Ladd or Nash
Duchene or Eberle
M.Richards or B.Schenn
Kessel or Neal
Subban or Myers
Toews or Stamkos
Clarkson or Lucic
Doughty or Petriangelo
- Cape Breton Bruins

I know you didn't ask me but

Seguin
Backes
Nash
Eberle
Richards
Kessel
Myers
Toews
Lucic
Pietrangelo

Pick one of each pair:

Seguin or Skinner
Backes or Kesler
Ladd or Nash
Duchene or Eberle
M.Richards or B.Schenn
Kessel or Neal
Subban or Myers
Toews or Stamkos
Clarkson or Lucic
Doughty or Petriangelo
- Cape Breton Bruins

seguin
last year would have said kesler but with another long term surgery recovery its close now
nash
duchene
richards for now
this one is tough, kessel has proven more with less, but neal adds size and grit so depends your needs
myers
stamkos even tho im a huge toews fan
doughty

Pick one of each pair:

Seguin or Skinner
Backes or Kesler
Ladd or Nash
Duchene or Eberle
M.Richards or B.Schenn
Kessel or Neal
Subban or Myers
Toews or Stamkos
Clarkson or Lucic
Doughty or Petriangelo
- Cape Breton Bruins

Ignoring contracts?
Sequin
Kesler
Nash
Eberle
Richards
Neal
Myers
Toews
Lucic
Doughty

Ignoring contracts?
Sequin
Kesler
Nash
Eberle
Richards
Neal
Myers
Toews
Lucic
Doughty
- prock

Mine were identical except I took Backes and Petriangelo.

Mine were identical except I took Backes and Petriangelo.
- Cape Breton Bruins

Doughty and Myers are my two favourite young Dmen in the league. I think they’re going to be the next era’s Nieds and Pronger (yes, I’m aware there are differences… like Myers isn’t nearly as nasty).

Doughty and Myers are my two favourite young Dmen in the league. I think they’re going to be the next era’s Nieds and Pronger (yes, I’m aware there are differences… like Myers isn’t nearly as nasty).
- prock

where does bogosian fall into that discussion

i think with the right development he could be a pronger light

where does bogosian fall into that discussion

i think with the right development he could be a pronger light
- nightmare3020

American...

American...
- Cape Breton Bruins

kesler, kessel, backes are american so didnt know this was strictly canadian

where does bogosian fall into that discussion

i think with the right development he could be a pronger light
- nightmare3020

A step behind. Maybe Jovanoski.

kesler, kessel, backes are american so didnt know this was strictly canadian
- nightmare3020

ahhh sorry I thought you were referring to Bogosian as a possible Pronger replacement on team Canada.

Probably somewhere around there. Close anyway.
- prock

Of the goalies you mentioned Lundqvist, Rinne, Kiprusoff, Thomas, Quick and Luongo are all better than Price. Miller and Vokoun Hiller and Backstrom have pretty similar stats than Price so i don't think you can say they are better plus Price has had a bad team in front of him this year. The remaining one is Halak who has yet to prove he can be a true number one goalie. Last year he started the season as the true number one and played only 57 games and had one of the worse save percentages of his career. Until he can play 60-70 games i don't know if i would put him on my list. Rask and Schnider look very good and could be added to the list if they become starters. I really don't think it is a stretch to put him in the top 10 and he probably should.

Of the goalies you mentioned Lundqvist, Rinne, Kiprusoff, Thomas, Quick and Luongo are all better than Price. Miller and Vokoun Hiller and Backstrom have pretty similar stats than Price so i don't think you can say they are better plus Price has had a bad team in front of him this year. The remaining one is Halak who has yet to prove he can be a true number one goalie. Last year he started the season as the true number one and played only 57 games and had one of the worse save percentages of his career. Until he can play 60-70 games i don't know if i would put him on my list. Rask and Schnider look very good and could be added to the list if they become starters. I really don't think it is a stretch to put him in the top 10 and he probably should.
- jordan456789

Over what? Last year? The last 3 years?

I just don't think that's true, so I'd like you to specify what you're looking at to come to that conclusion.

Of the goalies you mentioned Lundqvist, Rinne, Kiprusoff, Thomas, Quick and Luongo are all better than Price. Miller and Vokoun Hiller and Backstrom have pretty similar stats than Price so i don't think you can say they are better plus Price has had a bad team in front of him this year. The remaining one is Halak who has yet to prove he can be a true number one goalie. Last year he started the season as the true number one and played only 57 games and had one of the worse save percentages of his career. Until he can play 60-70 games i don't know if i would put him on my list. Rask and Schnider look very good and could be added to the list if they become starters. I really don't think it is a stretch to put him in the top 10 and he probably should.
- jordan456789

Miller is better then Price, dude. He has a vezina and an olympic Silver medal. Hiller is a question mark because of his vertigo but he was performing better. Vokoun is past his prime now I think Price is better and Backstrom has the same poop kind of team in front of him. He is on par as it is right now but Price has a higher ceiling obviously.

Over what? Last year? The last 3 years?

I just don't think that's true, so I'd like you to specify what you're looking at to come to that conclusion.
- prock

Going by the last 2 years. Price is only 24 so i am comparing what they have done recently. The other goalies are older so it is not fair to compare his first couple years in the league to theirs when they are in their prime.

Miller is better then Price, dude. He has a vezina and an olympic Silver medal. Hiller is a question mark because of his vertigo but he was performing better. Vokoun is past his prime now I think Price is better and Backstrom has the same poop kind of team in front of him. He is on par as it is right now but Price has a higher ceiling obviously.
- Cape Breton Bruins

Miller had one really good year and won the vezina but this year the save percentage is the same and last year Price had a better year. Closer than you think. Hiller was performing really well but not at the moment. For the list of goalies i mentioned there are arguments for each of them being better. Point is there is probably 6 elite goalies and the next is pretty open so I think Price is top 10

ahhh sorry I thought you were referring to Bogosian as a possible Pronger replacement on team Canada.
- Cape Breton Bruins

weber is pretty much that now

Miller had one really good year and won the vezina but this year the save percentage is the same and last year Price had a better year. Closer than you think. Hiller was performing really well but not at the moment. For the list of goalies i mentioned there are arguments for each of them being better. Point is there is probably 6 elite goalies and the next is pretty open so I think Price is top 10
- jordan456789

Miller's worst sv% over the past 4 years is .916. Price has only one better than that.

Miller >>> Price right now.

You're being a homer.

Going by the last 2 years. Price is only 24 so i am comparing what they have done recently. The other goalies are older so it is not fair to compare his first couple years in the league to theirs when they are in their prime.
- jordan456789

You're cherry picking stats to point out his career year.

Miller's worst sv% over the past 4 years is .916. Price has only one better than that.

Miller >>> Price right now.

You're being a homer.
- prock

There is absolutely no debate to the fact that Miller is a more accomplished and consistant goaltender then Price.

There is absolutely no debate to the fact that Miller is a more accomplished and consistant goaltender then Price.
- Cape Breton Bruins

There seems to be to some people.

Miller's worst sv% over the past 4 years is .916. Price has only one better than that.

Miller >>> Price right now.

You're being a homer.
- prock

Miller had a .916 the last two years so don't make it look like that is a bad year for him. He had one huge year where his his save percentage was 11 points higher than his next best season at a .918. I wasn't counting the first few years of Price's career because that is comparing his first years against MIller's prime years. Do you not see why i would do that? Would what he did the last 2 years not be a better indication of what he will do next year than what he did 3 or 4 years ago? If you want to go their entire career Price has a better save percentage and GAA than Miller.

Miller had a .916 the last two years so don't make it look like that is a bad year for him. He had one huge year where his his save percentage was 11 points higher than his next best season at a .918. I wasn't counting the first few years of Price's career because that is comparing his first years against MIller's prime years. Do you not see why i would do that? Would what he did the last 2 years not be a better indication of what he will do next year than what he did 3 or 4 years ago? If you want to go their entire career Price has a better save percentage and GAA than Miller.
- jordan456789

If you ask ANY non-Habs fan, if their team was gunning for a cup this year, who would they put in net if they had the choice, between Price and Miller, and 9 times out of 10, you’ll get Miller as an answer.

i think price is and will be a great goalie... but if im making a cup run or in game 7 i put miller in every time

i think price is and will be a great goalie... but if im making a cup run or in game 7 i put miller in every time
- nightmare3020

Yup, and in my opinion, you can say the same thing about 10+ more goalies in the NHL right now. That's all I'm saying.