So Dion is a top pairing dman on 29 teams?

Nice
- hon_hon_hon

Dion Phaneuf is a top pairing defenceman. Get over it.

For sure, i'd say he's top 15 dman in the league.

prob number 14 or 15 on the list if i had to make one.


Theres very few teams that have 2 of those that i would list above him.....
- JDBrickz

Make a list I'll be there to contradict you.

For sure, i'd say he's top 15 dman in the league.

prob number 14 or 15 on the list if i had to make one.


Theres very few teams that have 2 of those that i would list above him.....
- JDBrickz

Please show me that list.

Over Gio?

No chance.

Jbo or Wideman maybe.
- robin_steele264

A 27 point d-man or a 44 point d-man both sub-par defensively (I haven't seen Gio play that much really though)

Make a list I'll be there to contradict you.
- pker2theend

DAMN

*waits patiently*

A 27 point d-man or a 44 point d-man both sub-par defensively (I haven't seen Gio play that much really though)
- cor99

Hes awesome.

A 27 point d-man or a 44 point d-man both sub-par defensively (I haven't seen Gio play that much really though)
- cor99

Exactly.

He's also 3-4 years older than Hall, RNH... but yeah, he's the best now.

Nuge will take over though.
- robin_steele264

Hall too me won't be that great, but together your offense will be deadly...

Hall - RNH - Yakupov
Paajarvi - Gagner - Eberle

Maybe a different 2nd line C/LW but still on paper, that Top 6 is crazy talented. small, but fast and skilled

Dion Phaneuf is a top pairing defenceman. Get over it.
- dionschenn

I think he'd be great of he was paired with a real #1 and wasnt the captain and expected to do everything.

DAMN

*waits patiently*
- hon_hon_hon

there are bridges

Hall too me won't be that great, but together your offense will be deadly...

Hall - RNH - Yakupov
Paajarvi - Gagner - Eberle

Maybe a different 2nd line C/LW but still on paper, that Top 6 is crazy talented. small, but fast and skilled
- cor99

Hall will be an animal. Love the way he plays.

Exactly.
- hon_hon_hon

Still, from what I HAVE seen, and the stats, Gio to me had one good season (2010-11) and 2009-10 was alright.

Dion has had multiple very good seasons (first 2 or 3 seasons) and some good seasons (last season, 2010-11)

I would take Dion over Gio. I see nothing spectacular from Gio

Dion Phaneuf is a top pairing defenceman. Get over it.
- dionschenn

http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/story/?id=384805

So nothing happening, eh?

http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/story/?id=384805
- fidopro

A pretty girl can kiss a guy, a bird can kiss a butterfly, the rising sun can kiss the grass, but u my friend, yes you, you can kiss my

http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/story/?id=384805
- fidopro

Looks like he's doing something right.

Looks like other players don't like him. Which means he's doing his job.

A pretty girl can kiss a guy, a bird can kiss a butterfly, the rising sun can kiss the grass, but u my friend, yes you, you can kiss my
- bobbyisno1

http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/story/?id=384805
- fidopro

Jarome Iginla is also on that list.... is he over rated?

Just saw on twitter that Chris DiDomenico is a UFA.

We should take him back

Still, from what I HAVE seen, and the stats, Gio to me had one good season (2010-11) and 2009-10 was alright.

Dion has had multiple very good seasons (first 2 or 3 seasons) and some good seasons (last season, 2010-11)

I would take Dion over Gio. I see nothing spectacular from Gio
- cor99

Points aren't everything.

- robin_steele264

Points aren't everything.
- hon_hon_hon

Cool, but neither are overly good defensively. Both are offensive guys.

Cool, but neither are overly good defensively. Both are offensive guys.
- cor99

Make a mental to watch him play next season.

Just saw on twitter that Chris DiDomenico is a UFA.

We should take him back
- cor99

if we take him back then can we say we won that trade?

Just saw on twitter that Chris DiDomenico is a UFA.

We should take him back
- cor99

No but he is a future star, UG said so! How could nobody have snatched him up yet?