I wouldn’t. Look at the goalie turnover the last year. Grubauer, Vanacek, Dreiger, Kuemper, etc. Yes, I would love for another Quick ( aka a home-grown goalie talent) but I don’t think that it is essential to the ultimate success of this team. If Petersen can’t take the reigns, which I don’t think will happen, then there are plenty of other options in a year or two. Look to Samsonov in Wash, Georgiev in NYR, even Dreiger or Grub if one doesn’t fit in Seattle. Ultimately, I’m not worried about that position yet. Though I do think we need to make it a priority in the next draft or two.
- KingKopitar
So then there are realistically two options. Either the Kings decide to extend Petersen now, in which case he'll get Shesterkin/Samsonov money and term, or the Kings will decline to extend him and wait until after next season to see if Petersen can show if he's the real deal. There's no realistic situation in which Petersen extends now for the short-term or for less money.
The risk is if the Kings wait to extend him, and he puts up a top quality numbers this year, then the Kings are going to have to give him a Hellebuyck/Gibson contract next summer.
They're better off giving him a back-loaded 4-year, $4.5M deal so it will be buyout friendly if he turns out to be a bust. If he turns into the goalie that Robin Lehner says he is, then it will be one of the best goalie contracts in the NHL in a few years.