Nylander and 50% salary retained for Loui Eriksson?
- PatC80

Add Bracco and you have a deal.

You’re gonna be disappointed.
- Steven_Seagull

Idk why you guys expect me to fold..

Everything I’ve ever said about Nylander has turned out to be true.

Idk why you guys expect me to fold..

Everything I’ve ever said about Nylander has turned out to be true.
- Arctic_AARDVARK

Stay strong

Stay strong
- Canada Cup

He is, but something smells.

Idk why you guys expect me to fold..

Everything I’ve ever said about Nylander has turned out to be true.
- Arctic_AARDVARK

You said he’ll score 30+?

Don’t know why you fellers are even talking about trading Nylander. Dubas said he’s not trading him.

Don’t know why you fellers are even talking about trading Nylander. Dubas said he’s not trading him.
- DrunkenCanuck

Good plan, trade Marner.
He's just as one dimensional as Willy but he doesn't score.

Don’t know why you fellers are even talking about trading Nylander. Dubas said he’s not trading him.
- DrunkenCanuck

4th best forward, he's the odd man out.

Dubas said he wasn't trading him right away, he never said he'd never trade him.

He traded his BFF Kapanen, Nylander shouldn't be untouchable by any means.

Good plan, trade Marner.
- bobbyisno1

Robertson is a nice surprise. Playing with house money there. So package him with one of those tool bags like Dermott or Holl and get the D you need.

Robertson is a nice surprise. Playing with house money there. So package him with one of those tool bags like Dermott or Holl and get the D you need.
- DrunkenCanuck

Keep Robertson, trade Nylander

Good plan, trade Marner.
He's just as one dimensional as Willy but he doesn't score.
- bobbyisno1

1000% false. Marner is the only top forward who kills penalties and by far the best playmaker on the team and one of the best in the entire NHL when he's at his best. Marner is too young and too good to trade right now.

Keep Robertson, trade Nylander
- Steven_Seagull

Wrong wing, keep Robertson trade Marner.

Keep Robertson, trade Nylander
- Steven_Seagull

They aren't even close to the same level. Robertson is still terribly small, weak and can't skate for poop.

They definitely have to trade Nylander to fix the D but Robertson isn't filling his shoes any time soon.

1000% false. Marner is the only top forward who kills penalties and by far the best playmaker on the team and one of the best in the entire NHL when he's at his best. Marner is too young and too good to trade right now.
- JohnFergusonJr

Yeah and the Leafs had a really good penalty kill.

Don’t know why you fellers are even talking about trading Nylander. Dubas said he’s not trading him.
- DrunkenCanuck

He said he wouldn’t sign and trade.

They aren't even close to the same level. Robertson is still terribly small, weak and can't skate for poop.

They definitely have to trade Nylander to fix the D but Robertson isn't filling his shoes any time soon.
- JohnFergusonJr

Also, where was that playmaking against Columbus?

Yeah and the Leafs had a really good penalty kill.
- bobbyisno1

Columbus didn't score a single PP goal.

Also, where was that playmaking against Columbus?
- bobbyisno1

Ask Tavares who forgot how to hit an open net.

Ask Tavares and Matthews who made the spinning pass to win that game in OT.

Columbus didn't score a single PP goal.
- JohnFergusonJr

Because they have a terrible powerplay,how many did Boston score last year.

Ask Tavares who forgot how to hit an open net.

Ask Tavares and Matthews who made the spinning pass to win that game in OT.
- JohnFergusonJr

If Marner got his normal points per game like Nylander did they win that series.

Because they have a terrible powerplay,how many did Boston score last year.
- bobbyisno1

Or because the Leafs PK did it's job. You only like to blame but you won't give credit.

Marner, like Matthews, is 23 years old. Imagine being a Leafs fan so desperate for elite level talent and giving up on them at 23. It's as if people have been a Leafs fan for 10 minutes and haven't learn their lesson yet what happens when you start screaming to trade 23 year olds because they didn't deliver INSTANT gratification.

Or because the Leafs PK did it's job. You only like to blame but you won't give credit.

Marner, like Matthews, is 23 years old. Imagine being a Leafs fan so desperate for elite level talent and giving up on them at 23. It's as if people have been a Leafs fan for 10 minutes and haven't learn their lesson yet what happens when you start screaming to trade 23 year olds because they didn't deliver INSTANT gratification.
- JohnFergusonJr

So whats the difference giving up on Marner or Nylander. I think trading Marner would help the team much more, in trade return and cap. That's not giving up on him.

If Marner got his normal points per game like Nylander did they win that series.
- bobbyisno1

They both had 4 points each, what are you talking about?

Tavares had 3 points.

They all underachieved but they're all also very young. The only one that should be getting serious heat is Tavares. At his age and at this point in his career, he's been a playoff disappointment two years in a row.

It's understandable that young players will struggle but at 28-30, Tavares should be a lot better when it matters most.

If Marner got his normal points per game like Nylander did they win that series.
- bobbyisno1

You had a chance until Muzzin went down imo. Then the D got exposed and the big boys looked like they gave up.
67 year old Jason (frank)ing Spezza had to fight to get the smallest sputter of life out of the team. That’s a problem.
Just my toonie.

So whats the difference giving up on Marner or Nylander. I think trading Marner would help the team much more, in trade return and cap. That's not giving up on him.
- bobbyisno1

Because Marner has a way higher ceiling. It is absolutely is giving up on him.

Nylander + Johnsson / Kerfoot gives them the same cap space and enough trade value to get the job done.

Don't trade the best players with the highest ceilings. Trade the 4th best forward instead.