Johnsson, Bracco and 2020 2nd rd pick for Parayko.. Come on, do it Dubas
- PatC80

Not all of them
- PatC80

Pretty close....

5 years at 42 - 56 million per.
Total 247m
- Fakepartofme

Really? (frank) that's a lot.

They’re all overpaid for their terms.


- Garnie

- 21peter

This is a high class thread. How dare you post trailer trash in here?!?!

I would say Marner is 100% overpaid.

Matthews/Nylander/Tavares are market value at least in terms of what other teams would have offered (or did reportedly offer in Tavares case)
- Leafs43

So what’s the math on a 100% overpayment?

We'll see how overpaid MM is when he scores 100 points in the next 82 games you bastards.
- Zezel

But for which team...

So what’s the math on a 100% overpayment?
- Canada Cup

Simple, Divide by 2.

This is a high class thread. How dare you post trailer trash in here?!?!
- GreatGigInTheSky

The Johnnson moms are confused

We'll see how overpaid MM is when he scores 100 points in the next 82 games you bastards.
- Zezel

If he plays like he did in the playoffs again next year, what does it matter.

But for which team...
- 21peter

Exactly

All our top players are overpaid?
- Canada Cup

tavares was a ufa. needed to overpay to get him.

i know many disagree, but to me matthews and nylander are overpaid by about a mil each. and marner by 2.5 to 3.


that's 4.5 to 5m of cap space that would be pretty handy right now.

So what’s the math on a 100% overpayment?
- Canada Cup

5,446,500

Did you notice the incredibly clever way I suggested that he was an idiot without actually calling him one. We need more nuance in the world. I convince myself that people don’t laugh at my jokes because they are way too sophisticated. When I share this theory with my wife after we spend time with other people she has another interpretation. Anyway, we all do what we can.
- Canada Cup

I prefer the most frontal assault, just straight up say it to them.

If he plays like he did in the playoffs again next year, what does it matter.
- bixll

If he wins the Cup what does 11M matter

tavares was a ufa. needed to overpay to get him.

i know many disagree, but to me matthews and nylander are overpaid by about a mil each. and marner by 2.5 to 3.


that's 4.5 to 5m of cap space that would be pretty handy right now.
- Tumbleweed

Nylander isn't overpaid imo.

If he wins the Cup what does 11M matter
- Zezel

It doesn't..

I have to hear daily a 23 year-old Marner is so overpaid and useless, but people want to drop big money on Kyle Clifford. Christ.
- RogerRoeper

Really!!!!

Who's saying that????

I'm more than happy to let him walk

The Johnnson moms are confused
- Canada Cup

Him having so many moms confused me so much at the time.

But then I realised that it was the year and I felt dumb.

Nylander isn't overpaid imo.
- Scabeh

I thought Marner was the only guy that should pay back some to the Leafs... JMO

Really!!!!

Who's saying that????

I'm more than happy to let him walk
- dmnted

Nobody, Maybe JFJ, or UG I mean..

tavares was a ufa. needed to overpay to get him.

i know many disagree, but to me matthews and nylander are overpaid by about a mil each. and marner by 2.5 to 3.


that's 4.5 to 5m of cap space that would be pretty handy right now.
- Tumbleweed

Is it an overpay if he takes the least amount of money offered? Because that's what occurred. A little perspective is needed.


And Nylander is not worth 5.9.

Is it an overpay if he takes the least amount of money offered? Because that's what occurred. A little perspective is needed.


And Nylander is not worth 5.9.
- RogerRoeper

his contract was 45M over 6 years.

it should have been no more than $40M over 6 years imo.

tavares was a ufa. needed to overpay to get him.

i know many disagree, but to me matthews and nylander are overpaid by about a mil each. and marner by 2.5 to 3.


that's 4.5 to 5m of cap space that would be pretty handy right now.
- Tumbleweed

I'm convinced Matthews would have got a 12 million+ offersheet if he went RFA. So I don't consider him overpaid.

Marner is, because I really don't see any team ponying up the 4 first rounders for the right to pay him 10.5 million+

Financial issues being they dont want to sign him and spend it on other players. Not sure what your point is troll.
- Archaic

His point is he's lonely.