I don’t think Smith is IMO.

You put Smith on those Detroit teams and he’s nothing but a good running back.
- dadeadhead

Imagine if Sanders had the O line to run behind that Smith had in Dallas. Barry often had to beat two tacklers just to get back to the line. Some of his most amazing runs were for less than 5 yards, he’d scramble around & make 5 or 6 guys miss while trying to find some room to run. Meanwhile Smith was often untouched into the secondary with a full head of steam.

I just remember ek9 looking great with eichel.
Thought it was a outstanding season?
The kind of season that guys sign for 7+?

Eye test.

He was clearly a good player prior, and now after buffalo
- Boss34

Ya.
Eichel, albeit his earlier years did NOT enhance Kanes production.
Numbers don't lie about results.
Eye Test? Unless you attended say 20 - 30 games in both Winnipeg and San Jose is just local bias, homerism if you will...based purely on your perception of what (you think) you saw.

So, you can have your opinion, but realize it is just that, opinion.
The factual numbers for Sam and Evander relative to the notion of each living of Jack's coattails is just plain false.

I'll be happy to sign a Sam jersey for your friends daughter if it will make a difference!
I once penned a letter to a niece from Santa to help her understand that the surprise Puppy needs alot of love, play and training in their early years ... and then she will repay it over the next 12 or so years!
It worked well.
I can sign Skunk, Sam Reinfart if you like

The Saints have had some terrible luck these last few years.

Then there was a small stretch where they were in and out of the playoffs and a borderline playoff team because their defence couldn’t stop anybody.

It’s a team sport.

Rodgers for the better chunk of his career, apart from Devante Adams and Greg Jennings, has really been throwing to a bunch of nobodies.

Randall Cobb was average at best.
- Pegullaville

I heard somewhere Rodgers has a career total of ONE touchdown pass to a first round draft pick. Crazy if true