Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Anaheim Ducks :: would u do it??
Author Message
himel420
Montreal Canadiens
Location: Montreal, PQ
Joined: 08.20.2006

Jan 13 @ 6:29 PM ET
to mtl: gezlaf, perry, beauchemin

to anaheim: plekanec, gomez, gionta, weber, gill, 1st and 2nd

gallagher gezlaf perry
pacioretty deshairnais cole
bourque eller kostitsyn
darche nokaillen moen

subban beauchemin
markhov emellin
kaberle gorges

price is right

bureforearthsprez
Vancouver Canucks
Joined: 08.14.2009

Jan 13 @ 8:50 PM ET
Did you make this for a laugh?
Lahey
Edmonton Oilers
Location: del's basement chilling with S, AB
Joined: 03.07.2011

Jan 16 @ 10:23 AM ET
Did you make this for a laugh?
- bureforearthsprez

I cried
mfreedman
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Thornhill, ON
Joined: 10.04.2010

Jan 16 @ 12:56 PM ET
to mtl: gezlaf, perry, beauchemin

to anaheim: plekanec, gomez, gionta, weber, gill, 1st and 2nd

gallagher gezlaf perry
pacioretty deshairnais cole
bourque eller kostitsyn
darche nokaillen moen

subban beauchemin
markhov emellin
kaberle gorges

price is right

- himel420


Lol, I think your evaluation is way off..

Where is Tinordi? Why would anyone take Gomez?
TheTaoOfSemenko
Vegas Golden Knights
Joined: 07.01.2009

Jan 17 @ 1:05 PM ET
to mtl: gezlaf, perry, beauchemin

to anaheim: plekanec, gomez, gionta, weber, gill, 1st and 2nd

gallagher gezlaf perry
pacioretty deshairnais cole
bourque eller kostitsyn
darche nokaillen moen

subban beauchemin
markhov emellin
kaberle gorges

price is right

- himel420

theres not enough Anaheim fans on this site for this to draw the desired reaction. sry.
nightmare3020
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Windsor Area, ON
Joined: 08.23.2006

Jan 17 @ 3:11 PM ET
..... hummm i guess there is such a thing as stupid questions
mac6110
Anaheim Ducks
Location: CA
Joined: 07.16.2010

Jan 17 @ 11:19 PM ET
theres not enough Anaheim fans on this site for this to draw the desired reaction. sry.
- TheTaoOfSemenko

Oh there is. But this is rediculous. NO RESPONSE FOR YOU, COME BACK 1 WEEK
DuckNewbie
Anaheim Ducks
Location: West Niedermayer, CA
Joined: 07.28.2006

Jan 18 @ 12:58 PM ET
to mtl: gezlaf, perry, beauchemin

to anaheim: plekanec, gomez, gionta, weber, gill, 1st and 2nd

gallagher gezlaf perry
pacioretty deshairnais cole
bourque eller kostitsyn
darche nokaillen moen

subban beauchemin
markhov emellin
kaberle gorges

price is right

- himel420


Um....No.

Any trade that tries to swap quality for quantity will always be a fail!
mfreedman
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Thornhill, ON
Joined: 10.04.2010

Jan 18 @ 3:26 PM ET
Um....No.

Any trade that tries to swap quality for quantity will always be a fail!

- DuckNewbie


On a serious note, what would you want on top of the obvious of Schenn + Kadri for Getzlaf or Ryan? I just want to see how different an Anaheim evaluationis from a Toronto one.
DuckNewbie
Anaheim Ducks
Location: West Niedermayer, CA
Joined: 07.28.2006

Jan 18 @ 3:58 PM ET
On a serious note, what would you want on top of the obvious of Schenn + Kadri for Getzlaf or Ryan? I just want to see how different an Anaheim evaluationis from a Toronto one.
- mfreedman


Well, personally, I think it would be a big mistake to trade either Getzlaf or Ryan. Yes, the team had a rough go this season, but trading away guys who are REALLY hard to replace isn't the way to go! The basis for the "epic fail" this year seems to me to be more on the supporting staff end, followed by a loss of confidence at the top.

Look at our 3rd and 4th lines at the start of the season, and you see a whole lot of AHL quality, and retreads who took some time to fit in. That's been improved by some pickups, and guys coming off of injury, (Blake and Visnovsky). Maybe the recent upsurge, if it continues, will convince the Anaheim brass to let it ride, and build a better team from the bottom up next year....

As for Kadri and Schenn being the starting poing: I don't think we should take that risk. Will Kadri become a Ryan? Will Schenn blossom in Anaheim? Would a draft pick or two actually become NHL players? The answer, to me, is "Who knows?!" Throwing away NHL quality, (even if slumping), for big question marks is a recipe for failure.

Personally, I'm not sure Toronto is the best trading partner for the Ducks, anyway. (Particularly since Burkie seems to have Barstool Bob wrapped around his little finger).

I'd want PROVEN NHL QUALITY assets in return for either Getzlaf or Ryan. That isn't Schenn and Kadri. They still qualify only as "Maybe's".
bureforearthsprez
Vancouver Canucks
Joined: 08.14.2009

Jan 18 @ 4:19 PM ET
Well, personally, I think it would be a big mistake to trade either Getzlaf or Ryan. Yes, the team had a rough go this season, but trading away guys who are REALLY hard to replace isn't the way to go! The basis for the "epic fail" this year seems to me to be more on the supporting staff end, followed by a loss of confidence at the top.

Look at our 3rd and 4th lines at the start of the season, and you see a whole lot of AHL quality, and retreads who took some time to fit in. That's been improved by some pickups, and guys coming off of injury, (Blake and Visnovsky). Maybe the recent upsurge, if it continues, will convince the Anaheim brass to let it ride, and build a better team from the bottom up next year....

As for Kadri and Schenn being the starting poing: I don't think we should take that risk. Will Kadri become a Ryan? Will Schenn blossom in Anaheim? Would a draft pick or two actually become NHL players? The answer, to me, is "Who knows?!" Throwing away NHL quality, (even if slumping), for big question marks is a recipe for failure.

Personally, I'm not sure Toronto is the best trading partner for the Ducks, anyway. (Particularly since Burkie seems to have Barstool Bob wrapped around his little finger).

I'd want PROVEN NHL QUALITY assets in return for either Getzlaf or Ryan. That isn't Schenn and Kadri. They still qualify only as "Maybe's".

- DuckNewbie

Sometimes the status quo just can't get it done. Depth is huge in the league today.
mfreedman
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Thornhill, ON
Joined: 10.04.2010

Jan 18 @ 10:15 PM ET
Well, personally, I think it would be a big mistake to trade either Getzlaf or Ryan. Yes, the team had a rough go this season, but trading away guys who are REALLY hard to replace isn't the way to go! The basis for the "epic fail" this year seems to me to be more on the supporting staff end, followed by a loss of confidence at the top.

Look at our 3rd and 4th lines at the start of the season, and you see a whole lot of AHL quality, and retreads who took some time to fit in. That's been improved by some pickups, and guys coming off of injury, (Blake and Visnovsky). Maybe the recent upsurge, if it continues, will convince the Anaheim brass to let it ride, and build a better team from the bottom up next year....

As for Kadri and Schenn being the starting poing: I don't think we should take that risk. Will Kadri become a Ryan? Will Schenn blossom in Anaheim? Would a draft pick or two actually become NHL players? The answer, to me, is "Who knows?!" Throwing away NHL quality, (even if slumping), for big question marks is a recipe for failure.

Personally, I'm not sure Toronto is the best trading partner for the Ducks, anyway. (Particularly since Burkie seems to have Barstool Bob wrapped around his little finger).

I'd want PROVEN NHL QUALITY assets in return for either Getzlaf or Ryan. That isn't Schenn and Kadri. They still qualify only as "Maybe's".

- DuckNewbie


fair enough. So I assume you'd be looking for an even swap (i.e. similar to the Heatley for Havlat type deal)

If I were the GM though, I feel like if I were to be trading ne of those guys, and if I wanted proven talent, I'd make the trade for depth. Ship off a ton of unproven talent along with Ryan, and ask for a 2nd liner, 3rd liner, and top 4 d in return.

Then with the top 5 pick you get this year, draft Ryan's replacement, and you're bck in contention again next year.