Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 

Save for one season, McEichel era has been a dud for Edmonton and Buffalo

March 4, 2019, 11:55 AM ET [558 Comments]

RSSArchive
@boosbuzzsabres

Had we been shown the scheduled date of tonight's matchup between the Edmonton Oilers and Buffalo Sabres four years ago, we'd have thought that they'd be jousting for playoff positioning within their respective confernces heading into the game. With the two teams landing two franchise centers at the top the 2015 NHL Draft, what could go wrong?

Right?

Connor McDavid and Jack Eichel at the top of the 2015 Draft set off a mad scramble between two teams to finish in last place to secure at least one of them. The lottery system guaranteed that the last place team could drop no further than one spot and the Sabres "won" the last place trophy. However, they were jumped in the draft lottery by Edmonton, the NHL's third-worst team, who selected a transformative player in McDavid while Buffalo walked away with the "consolation prize" of franchise center Jack Eichel, who was taken second-overall. The two players will be forever linked far beyond the "McEichel" moniker placed upon them leading up to the draft and are still linked in that both of their organizations have floundered since selecting them.

For their parts, McDavid most definitely and Eichel to an extent have lived up to their hype, although the latter has taken a little longer to find his groove and credit to Edmonton for making it to the 2017 playoffs and coming to within one win of the conference finals. However, that playoff run has been the only success either franchise has tasted since the famous McEichel draft. The Oilers continue to be the Oilers despite McDavid and an additional three consecutive first overall picks, a third-overall, fourth-overall, seventh overall and 10th overall in the last eight years. They are on the verge of missing the playoffs for the 12th time in the last 13 seasons.

The Sabres had some tough luck in the draft lottery losing out in 2014 (selected Sam Reinhart second-overall) and 2015 (Eichel) but after a surprising last place finish in 2017-18 won the lottery and selected defenseman Rasmus Dahlin with the first pick that year. They've added three eighth-overall picks to that haul over the past six years but are on the verge of missing the playoffs for the eighth consecutive season and should the Carolina Hurricanes continue their surge to the post season, the Sabres will own the longest current playoff drought in the NHL.

After four years of McDavid and Eichel, both franchises should have been well along in the respective builds, but both have messed them up. We in Sabreland, unfortunately, have had a front row seat to the debacle unfolding in front of us. It began with the previous general manager emptying his cupboard to finish last then trying to rush a rebuild while throwing around draft picks and prospects for "young-vets." When it came time to rebuild around Eichel, the pieces he acquired didn't mesh, the supporting cast wasn't there and the team he put together was ill-equipped to play the style of play the coach wanted. After two years the coach and GM were both fired and after another year, all three young-vets that he traded for, along with the capital used to get them, were gone and the new GM had to start all over again.

That said, both teams have some very promising pieces and if the front offices can ever get it together they could turn into legit playoff teams. In addition to McDavid the Oilers have Ryan Nugent-Hopkins (1st-overall, 2011,) Oskar Klefbom (19th-overall, 2011) and the league's four-leading goal scorer, Leon Draisatl, who was drafted one pick after the Sabres selected Reinhart in 2014. The Sabres have Eichel, Reinhart, Dahlin and for the rest of the season, at least, forward Jeff Skinner, whom Buffalo GM Jason Botterill traded for over the summer.

In looking forward from 2015, one would have thought that these two teams would be much further along than 11th place in their respective conferences, but they're not. Although neither team is mathematically eliminated from playoff contention, the Sabres are nine points out of the second wild card spot in the East while the Oilers are eight points out in the West. Any glimmer of hope for either of these teams to make the playoffs could effectively be stamped out with a regulation loss tonight so at least they have something to play for other than pride. As of today, Moneypuck.com has the Oilers with a 4.46% chance of making the playoffs and the Sabres at 2.24%.

The two teams met in January at Edmonton and the Oilers steamrolled Buffalo 7-2 in a game that may have been even uglier than the final score would indicate. The Sabres had dropped out of a wild card spot in December but were still within reach at four points out but they lost two in a row to conference foes before getting smoked by Edmonton, a team that was two points out of a wild card spot in the West at the time.

Eichel and the Sabres have fared rather well vs. McDavid and the Oilers since the two were drafted in 2015. The teams have met seven times since with both players missing one game each in the series. Buffalo is 4-2-1 vs. Edmonton in the "McEichel" era.

Individually, McDavid hit the scoresheet with a goal and an assist in the January meeting while Eichel was held pointless. The totals between the two players in their careers vs. each other:

Eichel--6 games, 3 goals, 4 assists
McDavid--6 games, 3 goals, 3 assists


*****

From those at the rink for today's morning skate, here are Buffalo's lines and pairings:

Skinner-Eichel-Reinhart
Sheary-Rodrigues-Okposo
Wilson-Mittelstadt-Pominville
Girgensons-Larsson-Thompson

Dahlin-Bogosian
Scandella-Ristolainen
Hunwick-Montour


Sabres bench boss Phil Housley looks to have made one tweak up-front as he dropped winger Tage Thompson to the fourth line while 36 year old Jason Pominville gets moved up to play beside 20 yr. old rookie Casey Mittelstadt.

Housley's defense took a hit as it's been reported that Jake McCabe is out five to six weeks, or pretty much the rest of the season, with an upper body injury sustained in the Toronto game Saturday night. With McCabe out, Marco Scandella moves up a notch and Matt Hunwick moves from the press box to the third pairing.

Also from the rink, it looks as if goalie Linus Ullmark will get the nod tonight. This will be the third time this season Ullmark will have started three games in a row. The first set ran from Dec. 4-11 and the Sabres went 1-1-1 while the second set was Feb. 5-9 with the team going 2-0-1. Ullmark and the Sabres defeated the Pittsburgh Penguins 4-3 in overtime last Friday night then dropped a 5-2 decision in Toronto the next night leaving Ullmark 1-1 in this set.
Join the Discussion: » 558 Comments » Post New Comment
More from
» Not built for a rugged MassMutual East division
» The 2020-21 season is upon us. A look at the Buffalo Sabres
» Blue and Gold scrimmage, part II tonight. Jeff Skinner w/Curtis Lazar
» Sabres streaming tomorrow's scrimmage plus 2021 IIHF WJC notes
» It may take divine intervention for Buffalo to make the playoffs this year