So you're saying that players are only motivated by job security and only do as much as will guarantee them their current spot in the lineup?
I'm sure that's true in a good number of cases, but Giroux doesn't strike me as one of those guys that the coaches constantly need to light a fire under to get them to play at the level they're capable of (hello Hartsy). He also seems to live a pretty low-key off-ice life, so the Mike Richards factor isn't really there.
By all accounts, the kid is self-motivated, genuinely hard-working, and a coach's dream to work with.
- Tomahawk
In my opinion, a player's off ice life should be left out of it. None of us know what Giroux is doing in his spare time. There is no dedication or work ethic issue that is apparent with Giroux, just as there wasn't with Mike Richards.