...Point being is there was variability in the top 9 as a whole. The divide between top line producers and bottom line producers was not really that clear...
If that's the goal, which I agree it is...
When discussing the Forward lines, you really must consider the PK tandems. Sutter is on record as starting with a tandem, or a "two" to create lines, like Carter and Toffoli, or Kopi and Brown, or Stoll and Lewis in the past.
The ideal is to have the PK pairs play on the same lines, as during the Cup runs, especially 2012.
Sutter plans to roll 4 lines and builds those lines accordingly. He's not a Quenneville where 4th liners get scraps only, Sutter's 4th line predominantly is played in rotation like the rest of the lines.
Plus, Sutter has said he builds lines by starting with a "two" and adding the third forward to suit. Best case scenario is when those "twos" are the same as the PK tandems, again as in 2012. It's not something I made up, it's what Sutter does and has done.
So for me, it's Brown and Kopi, Carter and Toffoli as two main PK pairs. The match for Lewis is still undecided, although it evolved to Pearson much of the time because Shore didn't quite get "there" last year. Progress was made, and this year is make or break for Shore in my opinion. He has done every part of a 3C game really well at times, but not usually all in the same game. This year the parts need to become whole.
So to start I see this:
11 23
77 73
22
Then, since I like goals, and the Pearson Kopi Brown line has excellent stats, my third Forward for 11 and 23 is 70.
It seems clear that the third line Center should PK with Lewis. Shore was the candidate, and despite an uneven year I feel he showed progress in filling a very difficult role. So I pencil in Shore as a PK tandem with Lewis. Andreoff, or other, will be the 4th Center, maybe even swapping with Shore as to who gets the least minutes game to game.
70 11 23
77 73
21 22
15
Players left are Gaborik, King, Clifford, Purcell, Nolan and a Mersch or other.
The natural would be for Gaborik to play with Carter, but I want to roll 4 lines and I want offensive punch from all of them. Purcell is not strong enough defensively to play with Shore and Lewis, for me. He's okay at both sides, so that's a good thing.
If you get over the 4th line nomenclature and accept that balance is good (Pittsburgh with Kessel on a third line) you start looking openly for potential alignment of style and skills. Gaborik needs a partner, and his style and skills most closely match Andreoff.
Both Andreoff and Gaborik are fast, they even look the same as their strides are similar, they both can pass the puck, and Andreoff is showing signs of scoring and finishing touch. It may seem crazy but if you do plug in Andreoff and Gaborik just to see what is left, it suddenly works very well.
70 11 23
77 73
21 22
12 15 54
Players remaining are 74 and 13. King played a lot of time with 77 and 73 last year, and he can fill in on PK if needed. So you could conceivably rest Toffoli a PK without scrambling you lines by taking guys from different lines and playing them at the same time on a PK. If guys skate on different lines but PK together, your options are limited coming out of the PK because you could have two guys from two lines both too tired to take their shift. So you either skip one or even both of those lines to let them rest, or make up a new line by "frankensteining" from among rested players across
multiple lines. Not advisable. It's best to roll players every 4th shift, not sometimes the 4th, sometimes the 2nd or 3rd shift thru a game.
To say 13 and 74 are interchangeable is over-simplistic, but they can both move up and down lines. I prefer 74 with 77 and 73, out of existing familiarity. With the presence of Nolan, or Mersch/Dowd/other making it out of camp, we have flexibility with this starting alignment.
70 11 23
74/13/54 77 73
13/74 21 22
12 15 54/71
Voila. Balance. No discernible 4th line, instead it's two 3rd lines really. Centers go Left,Right,Right,Left. Pk pairs play on the same lines. Scoring tandems are kept intact except Gaborik and Kooi are split, but Pearson had better numbers than Gabo with 11 and 23. Gaborik and Andreoff can skate the first shift after a PK, with no line order interruption, and no adjustments to rest guys by making one-off lines.