I disagree because an elite goaltender can carry a team to the Stanley Cup and give them a chance, whereas an elite running back can't carry a team to the Super Bowl the same way.
Maybe you are comparing the totality of the goalie position to the totality of the running back position, but I think an elite goalie can prop a team up much more than an elite running back.
- j.boyd919
Goalies can often carry you to the cup, but how often is it the truly elite, highest paid goalies doing it?
Bobrovski - Has been wildly inconsistent and considered the worst contract in the sport before the last two years.
Hill - Was a backup level goalie who went on a run. Has now established himself as a starter but not considered big money elite.
Keumper - Has had 2-3 really good seasons and a lot of mediocrity around it.
Vasilevski - Exception here, top goalie making top money for 2 years.
Binnington - was a great goalie on a cheap contract.
Caps, Pens, Hawks all won without a big ticket elite goalie. There is little correlation between spending a ton of money on goaltending and winning cups. Its really just getting the most bang for your buck across your roster.